American Educational Research Journal · 1982 · 182 citations · 19 references
Social SciencesEducational PsychologyCognitive DevelopmentMedia StudiesStudent EngagementAcademic FunctioningMedia EffectsTelevision AudiencesTelevision StudiesAssessmentsChildren's Television AudiencesEducational TelevisionLeisure Time UseLive Television ViewingSample Size CalculationStudent Achievement EvidenceTelevision Consumption
The study synthesizes empirical evidence on how leisure‑time television viewing affects K‑12 student achievement. The authors compiled 274 correlations from 23 studies, coding sample traits, outcome types, study quality, viewing data collection, mean hours, and relationship strength. The meta‑analysis found a small negative overall correlation (–.05) between TV viewing and achievement, with a slight positive effect up to 10 hrs/week, turning negative beyond 10 hrs and worsening up to 35–40 hrs, and stronger adverse effects for females and high‑IQ children.
To integrate empirical findings concerning the impact of leisure time television viewing on student achievement in grades K-12, 274 correlations were assembled or calculated from 23 educational and psychological review articles, doctoral dissertations, statewide assessments, national surveys, articles from refereed journals, technical reports, books, and unpublished papers. For each study, characteristics of the sample, type of outcome, quality of the study, method of collecting viewing data, mean hours of viewing, and strength and direction of observed relationships were coded. The overall correlation of hours of televiewing and achievement is negative but small (–.05). Regardless of the sample size, year and location of the research, the effect remains consistent. The overall effect, however, is not constant across the range of viewing times. The effects are slightly positive for up to 10 hours of viewing a week, but beyond 10 hours the effects are negative and increasingly more deleterious until viewing time reaches 35 to 40 hours, beyond which additional viewing has little effect. Females and high IQ children are more adversely affected than other groups.
19
F. N. David, John W. Tukey · Biometrics · 1977 · 12.9K citations
John Osborn, John W. Tukey · Journal of the Royal Statistical Society Series A (General) · 1978 · 1.2K citations
The Scientific Basis of the Art of Teaching
DeVon L. Yoho, N. L. Gage · The Journal of Economic Education · 1979 · 541 citations