Management Science · 1990 · 477 citations · 20 references
BusinessBusiness AnalyticsManagement Information SystemsDecision AnalysisDecision TheoryForecastingData-driven Decision MakingDecision ModelingForecast CombinationForecast EvaluationForecasting MethodsManagerial Decision MakingExpert JudgmentForecast Combination EvaluationForecast Evaluation Under UncertaintyForecast Model ComparisonForecasting SystemsHeuristic ComputationIntuition In Decision MakingIntuitive Decision-making
We focus on ways of combining simple database models with managerial intuition. We present a model and method for isolating managerial intuition. For five different business forecasting situations, our results indicate that a combination of model and manager always outperforms either of these decision inputs in isolation, an average R 2 increase of 0.09 (16%) above the best single decision input in cross-validated model analyses. We assess the validity of an equal weighting heuristic, 50% model + 50% manager, and then discuss why our results might differ from previous research on expert judgment.
20
Expert and Novice Performance in Solving Physics Problems
John McDermott, Dorothea P. Simon, Herbert A. Simon · Science · 1980 · 2.1K citations
Robert Glaser, Ernest Rees · 1981 · 1.4K citations
Social Sciences, Physics, Psychology +13