Management Science · 1972 · 91 citations · 13 references
ManagementDecision SciencesDecision MakingDecision TheoryStrategic PlanningDecision Making In OrganizationsDecision-making ModelsDecision-making ProceduresDecision-making Under UncertaintyManagerial Decision MakingOrganizational Decision-makingDecision Under ConflictDecision-making ConflictDecision-making TheoryDecision-making Under ConflictDialectical ConflictDialectical LogicDialectical ThinkingStatistical Decision Theory
This paper presents a meta-logic of decision theory. It utilizes a dialectical formulation [Churchman, C. W. 1966. Hegelian inquiring systems. Internal Working Paper 49, Space Sciences Laboratory, Social Sciences Project, University of California, Berkeley, September; Mason, R. O. 1969. A dialectical approach to strategic planning. Management Sci. 15(8, April) B-403–B-414; Mitroff, I. I. 1971. A communication model of dialectical inquiring systems—A strategy for strategic planning. Management Sci. 17(10, June) B-634–648.] as a prescriptive methodology for minimizing statistical decision errors of the third kind; i.e., the error of solving the “wrong” decision problem when one should have solved the “right” problem. The dialectical formulation is chosen because it is the only existent methodological form which both utilizes conflict over value issues in a productive fashion and ensures a minimal sense of completeness in the decision-space of possible problem choice [Mitroff, I. I. On the general problem of building a generalized model of general models (in preparation).]. The result is the development of a meta-theory of decision-making. It is argued that the concept of a Dialectical Inquiring System [Mitroff, I. I. 1971. A communication model of dialectical inquiring systems—A strategy for strategic planning. Management Sci. 17(10, June) B-634–648; Mitroff, I. I. On the general problem of building a generalized model of general models (in preparation).] is to our meta-theory of decision-making as the concept of a lottery [Pratt, J. W., H. Raiffa, R. Schlaifer. The foundations of decision under uncertainty: An elementary exposition. J. Amer. Stat. Assoc. 59 353–375.] is to the ordinary theory of decision-making.
13
On the Epistemology of the Inexact Sciences
Olaf Helmer, Nicholas Rescher · Management Science · 1959 · 529 citations
Humanities, Philosophy, Epistemology +10
A Dialectical Approach to Strategic Planning
Richard O. Mason · Management Science · 1969 · 409 citations
Prediction and Optimal Decision.
N. Smith, C. West Churchman · Journal of the American Statistical Association · 1961 · 172 citations