Recovering from HSPS (Hyperactive Superficial Principal Syndrome): A Progress Report

Kim Marshall

Phi Delta Kappan · 2003 · 24 citations · 1 references

Concepts

Abstract

In a previous article, Mr. Marshall shared with Kappan readers the innovative system he developed during his early years as a principal - short classroom visits followed by informal feedback. But that system alone, he found, was not enough to bring about significant gains in student achievement. In the intervening years, he has learned that four complementary activities are necessary to achieve the primary goal of instructional leadership. SEVEN YEARS ago, I wrote an article for the Kappan that was featured on the cover. It carried a long-winded title: I Confronted HSPS (Hyperactive Superficial Principal Syndrome) and Began to Deal with the Heart of the Matter. In the piece, I described my unsuccessful struggle as a rookie principal to get into classrooms and talk substance with teachers. Then I shared my discovery of what seemed like a good solution: making five-minute visits to five classrooms a day and tracking down each teacher later on (within 24 hours if possible) for a follow-up conversation. The article did not generate much mail, but it has been widely read and discussed, and (perhaps not as a direct result) the idea of short classroom visits seems to have gained some acceptance.1 How have I handled teacher supervision since 1996? Did I keep doing five-minute visits? How did teachers react? And most important, did this system make a difference for student achievement? An Update The short answer is that I kept up my visits, averaging four a day (about 500 a year) for a total of eight years. Teachers were quite positive about this approach to supervision, and I firmly believe that it was an essential part of my instructional leadership. But classroom visits and feedback did not by themselves produce significant student achievement gains. I'll return to this point below. First, some background. In my early years as a principal, I was constantly swamped by over-the-transom demands on my time - a weeping girl with a splinter under her fingernail, a fight in the cafeteria, a teacher going through a personal crisis, a dog sneaking into the school, a parent cursing to the secretary about a bully on the bus, a jammed photocopier, a paraprofessional having a seizure, the laminating machine grabbing the end of my favorite tie, a call from the central office in support of that angry parent, a delivery from a trucker who refused to lift anything, and more. I aspired to be an instructional leader, but I simply didn't have the time to do teacher supervision the way I'd been taught it was supposed to be - the canonical preconference, whole-class observation, and postconference debriefing. I also realized that there was no way that I could be the staff developer for the school, as I had naively hoped I would be. Chatting with other principals and perusing reality-based professional literature, I realized that I was not alone. The dirty little secret of American schools is that principals rarely get into classrooms. Powerful, almost inexorable forces conspire to keep school administrators from a meaningful instructional role. The result is Hyperactive Superficial Principal Syndrome (HSPS), and it looks like this: * the principal is trapped in the office dealing with one crisis after another; * if the principal escapes, he or she wanders around without a clear agenda and misses a lot; * each day is so chopped up by interruptions that it's very hard to focus on deeper stuff; * teachers are rarely observed in a thoughtful way and almost never get feedback; * evaluation visits happen only when they are absolutely required, which is usually once every year or two; * evaluators often see glamorized lessons that aren't very representative of daily practice; * evaluations are sometimes based on rumor, gossip, and innuendo and are not very deep; * there are few authentic teaching/learning conversations between teachers and principals; * teachers are mostly on their own and get used to working in isolation; and * starved for feedback, many teachers stagnate, and mediocrity flourishes. …

References

1