Inequality of what? Social exclusion in the e‐society as capability deprivation

Yingqin Zheng, Geoff Walsham

Information Technology and People · 2008 · 226 citations · 38 references

Concepts

TL;DR

The study aims to examine social exclusion in the e‑society from a human‑development perspective, emphasizing options, choice, and opportunities beyond mere distribution of technology, and introduces Sen’s capability approach as a novel analytical lens. Using an interpretivist design, the authors apply Sen’s capability framework to analyze two empirical cases from South Africa and China, illustrating how capability deprivation manifests across different social spaces. The analysis reveals relational aspects of social exclusion, identifies various forms of capability deprivation, and exposes the phenomenon of “unfavourable inclusion” that can be obscured by technological diffusion, while offering policy recommendations that extend beyond technological provision to address socio‑political, cultural, and institutional barriers. This work represents an early application of the capability approach to ICT studies in developing countries.

Abstract

Purpose The purpose of this paper is to engage with the debate on social exclusion in the e‐society from the human development perspective, which goes beyond inequality in distribution of technological goods and services to emphasise the options, choice and opportunities related to accessing and using information. Design/methodology/approach This is an interpretivist study. It draws on Sen's capability approach (CA) to conceptualise social exclusion in the e‐society as capability deprivation, both in well‐being and agency freedom. A framework of the core aspects of the CA is used to analyse two empirical studies in South Africa and China which serve to illustrate social exclusion manifested as capability deprivation in different “spaces”. Findings The paper demonstrates the relational features of social exclusion and different types of capability deprivation in e‐society; highlights “unfavourable inclusion” which can be masked by technological diffusion. Research limitations/implications This paper is an early attempt to apply the capability approach to social studies of information communication technologies in developing countries. Practical implications The paper provides implications for government policies to go beyond technological provision and pay attention to socio‐political, cultural and institutional aspects in ensuring effective utilisation of information and channels of communication, which should serve to enhance people's opportunity to better participate in economic, social and political activities. Originality/value The paper is a novel attempt to apply concepts of the CA in information systems, which provides a conceptual lens to address the complexity and multiplicity of social exclusion in the e‐society.

References

38