Exploring Management Consulting Firms as Knowledge Systems

Andreas Werr, Torbjörn Stjernberg

Organization Studies · 2003 · 319 citations · 40 references

Concepts

TL;DR

Management consulting firms generate, disseminate, and translate knowledge through a system of methods, cases, and consultant experience, a framework that contrasts with prior studies focusing solely on articulate or tacit knowledge. The study argues that effective knowledge management in consulting hinges on understanding how methods, cases, and individual experience interrelate. Using case studies of Andersen Consulting (now Accenture) and Ernst & Young (now Cap Gemini Ernst & Young), the authors identify and analyze the interactions among methods, cases, and consultant experience. They find that articulate knowledge supports rather than replaces consultant experience, enabling diverse learning and complementing structural and individual knowledge.

Abstract

This article examines the nature and the generation, dissemination and translation of knowledge in large, global management consulting organizations. The knowledge system in consulting organizations is modelled as consisting of three interacting knowledge elements: methods and tools, providing a common language and knowledge structure; cases, carrying knowledge in a narrative form; and the experience of individual consultants that is essential for the adaptation of methods, tools and cases to the specific consulting project. A number of recent studies have characterized knowledge-management strategies as focusing on either articulate knowledge or tacit knowledge. We argue that a fruitful understanding of knowledge management in management consulting requires attention to the relations between the different elements that represent different kinds of knowledge. Based on case studies in Andersen Consulting (now Accenture) and Ernst & Young Management Consulting (now Cap Gemini Ernst & Young) these knowledge elements and the interplay between them are identified and analysed. The main role of articulate knowledge is not to replace experience, but rather to support the generation, dissemination and use of it. A number of consequences of this conceptualization of the knowledge system are discussed in terms of the ability of the knowledge system to generate different types of learning and the complementarity of structural and individual knowledge.

References

40