Dilemmatics in Public Sector Assessment: A Framework for Developing and Evaluating Selection Systems

James T. Austin, Richard J. Klimoski, Steven T. Hunt

Human Performance · 1996 · 15 citations · 56 references

Concepts

Abstract

Working from the premise that validity is necessary but not sufficient for effective long-term selection system operation, we propose a framework that recognizes multiple, often conflicting standards for evaluating public sector selection systems. Three clusters of standards that represent procedural justice-fairness, scientific-tech- nical adequacy, and feasibility-utility are identified and discussed. Stakeholder groups that include political entities, management, labor unions, and system designers (internal and external consultants) often order these standards differently. When applied to a unionized environment, the framework suggests that optimizing all sets of standards may be a better strategy than maximizing any one set. Advice is presented for general and specific cases that may confront the researcher or practitioner.

References

56