Medical Teacher · 2009 · 18 citations · 7 references
MedicineInternal MedicineMedical EducationClinical MedicineGeneral Internal MedicineResidency TrainingClinical EvaluationCompetency AssessmentStandardized ExaminationsAssessment Of Professional CompetenceAssessment Of Professional PracticeAssessment Of Professional SkillsAssessment Of Trainee CompetenceEvaluation Of KnowledgeMedical Professional OrganizationsMultiple-choice QuestionsPrincipal Components
BACKGROUND: As society's expectations of physicians change, so must the objectives of training. Professional organizations involved in training now emphasize multiplicity of roles. But how well do we evaluate these multiple roles? AIMS: To investigate the principal components of evaluation in the Internal Medicine clerkship rotation at the University of Calgary. METHODS: We performed factor analysis on all evaluation components in the Internal Medicine clerkship rotation, including the in-training evaluation report (ITER), objective structured clinical examination (OSCE), and multiple choice questions (MCQ) examination. RESULTS: We identified three principal components: information processing, professionalism, and declarative knowledge. Both the OSCE and MCQ loaded on a single factor, declarative knowledge. The nine items on the ITER loaded on two factors-information processing and professionalism. CONCLUSIONS: Despite using 11 evaluation items on three tools, we identified only three principal components of evaluation. Both our MCQ and OSCE appeared to measure declarative knowledge. The latter may be due to the fact that we use standardized patients without clinical findings-such that evaluations are primarily based upon the demonstration of examination routines. Reasons for the lack of discriminant validity of our ITER include overlapping attributes and constant errors, including a halo effect and an error of leniency.
7
Foundations of Behavioral Research
Rex Stockton, Fred N. Kerlinger · American Educational Research Journal · 1974 · 7.4K citations
A constant error in psychological ratings.
Edward L. Thorndike · Journal of Applied Psychology · 1920 · 2.1K citations
The Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons of Canada
The Canadian Journal of Psychiatry · 1962 · 358 citations