Journal of Speech Language and Hearing Research · 2011 · 130 citations · 45 references
EducationSpecial EducationSpeech-language PathologyPediatric DisabilityPediatric Rehabilitation MedicinePediatric Speech-language PathologyApraxia Of SpeechBehavior TherapyMotor Speech DisordersPractice SchedulesSpeech RehabilitationAccuracyApraxia Of Speech TreatmentIntegral StimulationMotor-based InterventionPediatric Speech TherapyPediatric Speech-language InterventionPerceptual AccuracySpeech Therapy Intervention
Prior literature suggests random practice may benefit childhood apraxia of speech, yet no systematic comparison with blocked practice has been conducted. The study compares the effects of random versus blocked practice schedules in treating childhood apraxia of speech. Using an alternating‑treatments single‑subject design with multiple baselines across behaviors, the authors compared random and blocked practice in four CAS children, scoring perceptual accuracy of target utterances and calculating effect sizes. Results were mixed, with two children benefiting more from blocked practice, one from random practice, and one showing no clear improvement; thus, the random‑practice advantage seen in nonspeech motor learning may not apply to CAS treatment, though integral stimulation can still improve speech production.
Purpose To compare the relative effects of random vs. blocked practice schedules in treatment for childhood apraxia of speech (CAS). Although there have been repeated suggestions in the literature to use random practice in CAS treatment, no systematic studies exist that have directly compared random with blocked practice in this population. Method Using an alternating treatments single-subject design with multiple baselines across behaviors, the authors compared random and blocked practice in 4 children diagnosed with CAS in terms of retention and transfer. Random and blocked practice were implemented in the context of a version of Dynamic Temporal and Tactile *Cueing treatment (Strand, Stoeckel, & Baas, 2006). Perceptual accuracy of target utterances was scored, and effect sizes were calculated to quantify the magnitude of treatment effects. Results Findings were mixed, with 2 children showing a blocked practice advantage, 1 child showing a random practice advantage, and 1 child showing no clear improvement in either condition. Conclusions These findings suggest that the random practice advantage observed in the nonspeech motor learning literature may not extend to treatment for CAS. Furthermore, the findings add to the small body of literature indicating that integral stimulation treatment can lead to improvements in speech production for children with CAS.
45
An fMRI investigation of syllable sequence production
Jason W. Bohland, Frank H. Guenther · NeuroImage · 2006 · 556 citations