Does Perspective-Taking Increase Patient Satisfaction in Medical Encounters?

Benjamin Blatt, Susan LeLacheur, Adam D. Galinsky, Samuel J. Simmens, Larrie Greenberg

Academic Medicine · 2010 · 148 citations · 35 references

Concepts

TL;DR

Perspective‑taking is a promising strategy to enhance patient satisfaction in clinical settings. The study examined whether perspective‑taking instruction improves patient satisfaction during student‑clinician encounters with standardized patients. Three randomized studies with 608 students across two universities and a physician assistant program assessed satisfaction after a perspective‑taking or neutral instruction before clinical skills exams. Perspective‑taking increased patient satisfaction in all studies, with larger effects for African American standardized patients and students with high baseline perspective‑taking, and no benefit for low‑baseline students.

Abstract

To assess whether perspective-taking, which researchers in other fields have shown to induce empathy, improves patient satisfaction in encounters between student-clinicians and standardized patients (SPs).In three studies, randomly assigned students (N = 608) received either a perspective-taking instruction or a neutral instruction prior to a clinical skills examination in 2006-2007. SP satisfaction was the main outcome in all three studies. Study 1 involved 245 third-year medical students from two universities. Studies 2 and 3 extended Study 1 to examine generalizability across student and SP subpopulations. Study 2 (105 physician assistant students, one university) explored the effect of perspective-taking on African American SPs' satisfaction. Study 3 (258 third-year medical students, two universities) examined the intervention's effect on students with high and low baseline perspective-taking tendencies.Intervention students outscored controls in patient satisfaction in all studies: Study 1: P = .01, standardized effect size = 0.16; Study 2: P = .001, standardized effect size = 0.31; Study 3: P = .009, standardized effect size = 0.13. In Study 2, perspective-taking improved African American SPs' satisfaction. In Study 3, intervention students with high baseline perspective-taking tendencies outscored controls (P = .0004, standardized effect size = 0.25), whereas those with low perspective-taking tendencies did not (P = .72, standardized effect size = 0.00).Perspective-taking increased patient satisfaction in all three studies, across medical schools, clinical disciplines, and racially diverse students and SPs. Perspective-taking as a means for improving patient satisfaction deserves further exploration in clinical training and practice.

References

35