Applied Cognitive Psychology · 2008 · 57 citations · 26 references
BusinessDecision SciencesDecision TheoryForecastingWeather ForecastingCommunication About UncertaintyForecast UncertaintyForecasting UncertaintyFraming EffectsSevere Weather ForecastingUncertainty PerceptionDecision-making Under Weather UncertaintyForecast Probability JudgmentsForecast Uncertainty AssessmentLikelihood FramingProbability Framing EffectsUncertainty FramingUser ExpectationsVerbal Expression
Abstract Many believe that information about small chances of severe weather would be useful to the general public for precautionary action. What is the best way to explain this kind of information to a non‐expert audience? The studies reported here investigated effects of framing (negative vs. positive), format (frequency vs. probability), likelihood (low vs. high) and compatibility (task‐match) on interpretation of verbal expressions of forecast uncertainty and on subsequent forecasting decisions. The crucial factor was the match between the verbal expression and the overall task goal. Errors increased when there was a mismatch between the expression (e.g. winds less than 20 knots) and the task (e.g. post an advisory when winds will exceed 20 knots). However, framing and format had little impact. We conclude that consideration of user expectations arising from the overall task goal is crucial in explaining uncertainty information to a naïve audience. Global expectations overpower other potential effects. Copyright © 2008 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
26
On the Elicitation of Preferences for Alternative Therapies
Barbara J. McNeil, Stephen G. Pauker, Harold C. Sox et al. · New England Journal of Medicine · 1982 · 1.7K citations