Research Papers in Education · 2015 · 10 citations · 19 references
EducationDecision SciencesCriterion-referenced AssessmentDecision AnalysisStandard-settingExpert ModelingExpertise AssessmentStandard-setting For Certification ExaminationsStandard-setting ReliabilityStandard-setting ValidityStandards-based AssessmentAssessor JudgementExpert JudgmentScientific Examination StandardsStandard-setting Method Comparison
In recent years the use of expert judgement to set and maintain examination standards has been increasingly criticised in favour of approaches based on statistical modelling. This paper reviews existing research on this controversy and attempts to unify the evidence within a framework where expertise is utilised in the form of comparative judgement. Initially, the paper introduces a mathematical model for the way in which comparative judgement may operate. Data from existing studies of comparative judgement are then used to estimate suitable parameters for this model. Having derived a working mathematical model for the operation of expert judgement, the paper will then demonstrate that this model provides results that are broadly consistent with existing research, including both studies that are critical and studies that are supportive of the use of expert judgement. The model will then be applied to examine the required scale and design of expert-driven approaches to standard maintaining in order for these to have any chance of being as reliable as the currently favoured, purely statistical approaches. The paper also discusses the minimum conditions required for this approach to designing expert-driven approaches to be appropriate.
19
A law of comparative judgment.
L. L. Thurstone · Psychological Review · 1927 · 5.2K citations
Lloyd G. Humphreys, E. F. Lindquist · The American Journal of Psychology · 1952 · 1.5K citations
RANK ANALYSIS OF INCOMPLETE BLOCK DESIGNS
Ralph A. Bradley, Milton E. Terry · Biometrika · 1952 · 1.4K citations