The Nature of Responsibility: Children's Understanding of "Your Job"

Pamela M. Warton, Jacqueline J. Goodnow

Child Development · 1991 · 43 citations · 20 references

Concepts

TL;DR

Research on responsibility gains clarity when it is defined by specific principles such as direct‑cause, self‑regulation, and continuing responsibility. The study aims to investigate how children understand responsibility by defining it through these three principles. The authors used vignettes and a sorting task about household chores to assess children’s judgments of fairness across the three principles. Results reveal that children’s grasp of responsibility develops differently for each principle, indicating a non‑unitary concept that opens avenues for further research on distributive norms.

Abstract

The present study starts from the argument that research on responsibility will benefit from defining it in terms of some specific principles. The 3 principles considered deal with the sharing or distribution of work. They are (a) direct-cause responsibility (e.g., people should fix problems they have created), (b) self-regulation (e.g., you should not expect to be reminded), and (c) continuing responsibility (e.g., a job remains “yours” even when someone else agrees to do it). These principles were embedded in vignettes and a sorting task, all related to household work, with children of 8, 11, or 14 years of age commenting on the fairness of various work arrangements. The results show differential developmental paths for the 3 principles rather than a unitary sense of responsibility. The redefinition emerges as providing both a way to generate new research on responsibility and a link to studies of distributive norms dealing with rewards or rights.

References

20