Academic Emergency Medicine · 2013 · 46 citations · 33 references
Veterinary MedicineEmergency MedicineInfectious DiseasesBladder ManagementDiagnostic MicrobiologyFemale UrologyUrinary Tract Infection DiagnosticsUrinary Tract InfectionsDiagnostic Accuracy StudiesDiagnostic Testing AccuracyDiagnostic UrinalysisLaboratory TestingMicroscopic UrinalysisQuality AssessmentUrinalysis ScreeningUrine Culture Interpretation
Emergency physicians often encounter females presenting with symptoms suggestive of urinary tract infections (UTIs). The diagnostic accuracy of history, physical examination, and bedside laboratory tests for female UTIs in emergency departments (EDs) have not been quantitatively described. This was a systematic review to determine the utility of history and physical examination (H&P) and urinalysis in diagnosing uncomplicated female UTI in the ED. The medical literature was searched from January 1965 through October 2012 in PUBMED and EMBASE using the following criteria: Patients were females greater than 18 years of age in the ED suspected of having UTIs. Interventions were H&P and urinalysis used to diagnose a UTI. The comparator was UTI confirmed by a positive urine culture. The outcome was operating characteristics of the interventions in diagnosing a UTI. Study quality was assessed using Quality Assessment Tool for Diagnostic Accuracy Studies (QUADAS-2). Sensitivity, specificity, and likelihood ratios (LRs) were calculated using Meta-DiSc. Four studies (pooled n = 948) were included with UTI prevalence ranging from 40% to 60%. H&P variables all had positive LRs (+LR, range = 0.8 to 2.2) and negative LRs (–LR, range = 0.7 to 1.0) that are insufficient to significantly alter pretest probability of UTI. Only a positive nitrite reaction (+LR = 7.5 to 24.5) was useful to rule in a UTI. To rule out UTI, only a negative leukocyte esterase (LE; −LR = 0.2) or blood reaction on urine dipstick (–LR = 0.2) were significantly accurate. Increasing pyuria directly correlated with +LR, and moderate pyuria (urine white blood cells [uWBC] > 50 colony-forming units [CFUs]/ml) and moderate bacteruria were good predictors of UTI (+LR = 6.4 and 15.0, respectively). No single H&P finding can accurately rule in or rule out UTI in symptomatic women. Urinalysis with a positive nitrite or moderate pyuria and/or bacteruria are accurate predictors of a UTI. If the pretest probability of UTI is sufficiently low, a negative urinalysis can accurately rule out the diagnosis. La Historia Clínica y la Exploración Física junto a las Pruebas Complementarias de Laboratorio para el Diagnóstico de la Infección del Tracto Urinario en las Mujeres Adultas Los urgenciólogos a menudo se encuentran con mujeres que presentan síntomas sugestivos de infección del tracto urinario (ITU). La certeza diagnóstica de la historia clínica, la exploración física y las pruebas complementarias de laboratorio a pie de cama para las mujeres con ITU en el servicio de urgencias (SU) no se ha descrito cuantitativamente. Revisión sistemática para determinar la utilidad de la historia clínica y la exploración física (H+E) y el urinoanálisis (UA) en el diagnóstico de la ITU no complicada en la mujer en el SU. Se buscó literatura médica desde enero de 1965 hasta octubre de 2012 en PUBMED y EMBASE usando los siguientes criterios: como pacientes se consideraron mujeres mayores de 18 años de edad en el SU con sospecha de tener una ITU; como intervenciones la utilización de H+E y UA para diagnosticar una ITU; como comparador se usó la ITU confirmada mediante un urinocultivo positivo; y como resultado las características operacionales de las intervenciones en el diagnóstico de una ITU. La calidad del estudio se valoró mediante el QUADAS-2. Se calculó la sensibilidad, la especificidad y las razones de probabilidad mediante Meta-Disc. Se incluyeron cuatro estudios (del total n = 948 pacientes) con un rango de prevalencia de ITU del 40% al 60%. Las variables H+E tuvieron todas una razón de probabilidad positiva (RP+) entre 0,8 a 2,2, y negativa (RP-) entre 0,7 a 1,0, lo que es una probabilidad pretest de ITU de insuficiente a significativamente alterada. Sólo una reacción a nitritos positiva (RP+ de 7,5 a 24,5) fue útil para diagnosticar una ITU. Para descartar una ITU, sólo una reacción a esterasa leucocitaria negativa (RP- 0,2) o una reacción a hematíes en una tira de orina (RP- 0,2) fueron significativamente certeras. El incremento de la piuria se correlacionó directamente con la RP+, y la piuria moderada (>50 leucocitos por campo en orina) y la bacteriuria moderada fueron buenos factores predictivos de ITU (RP+ 6,4 y 15,0, respectivamente). Ningún hallazgo aislado en la H+E puede certeramente diagnosticar o descartar una ITU en mujeres sintomáticas. El UA con nitritos positivos o una moderada piuria y/o bacteriuria son factores predictivos certeros de una ITU. Si la probabilidad pretest de ITU es suficientemente baja, un UA negativo puede descartar certeramente el diagnóstico. CME Editor: Hal Thomas, MD Authors: Lisa Meister, MD, Eric J. Morley, MD, Diane Scheer, MD, and Richard Sinert, DO Article Title: History and Physical Examination Plus Laboratory Testing for the Diagnosis of Adult Female Urinary Tract Infection If you wish to receive free CME credit for this activity, please refer to the website: http://www.wileyhealthlearning.com. Accreditation and Designation Statement: Blackwell Futura Media Services designates this journal-based CME activity for a maximum of 1 AMA PRA Category 1 CreditTM. Physicians should only claim credit commensurate with the extent of their participation in the activity. Blackwell Futura Media Services is accredited by the Accreditation Council for Continuing Medical Education to provide continuing medical education for physicians. Educational Objectives After completing this exercise the participant will be able to explain the relative roles of the various components of the diagnostic assessment for small bowel obstructions in adults. Activity Disclosures No commercial support has been accepted related to the development or publication of this activity. Faculty Disclosures: CME editor – Hal Thomas, MD: No relevant financial relationships to disclose. Authors –Lisa Meister, MD, Eric J. Morley, MD, Diane Scheer, MD, and Richard Sinert, DO This manuscript underwent peer review in line with the standards of editorial integrity and publication ethics maintained by Academic Emergency Medicine. The peer reviewers have no relevant financial relationships. The peer review process for Academic Emergency Medicine is double-blinded. As such, the identities of the reviewers are not disclosed in line with the standard accepted practices of medical journal peer review. Conflicts of interest have been identified and resolved in accordance with Blackwell Futura Media Services's Policy on Activity Disclosure and Conflict of Interest. No relevant financial relationships exist for any individual in control of the content and therefore there were no conflicts to resolve. Instructions on Receiving Free CME Credit For information on applicability and acceptance of CME credit for this activity, please consult your professional licensing board. This activity is designed to be completed within an hour; physicians should claim only those credits that reflect the time actually spent in the activity. To successfully earn credit, participants must complete the activity during the valid credit period, which is up to two years from initial publication. Follow these steps to earn credit: This activity will be available for CME credit for twelve months following its publication date. At that time, it will be reviewed and potentially updated and extended for an additional twelve months. Urinary tract infection (UTI) is a common diagnosis for females who present to the emergency department (ED), accounting for over 1 million visits yearly.1 With such a common disease, emergency physicians must not only concern themselves with correctly making the diagnosis of UTI, but deciding on a diagnostic to of with the concern of in their The to or not to a with symptoms of UTI is by the history and physical examination (H&P) and urinalysis these provide to a diagnosis of UTI, the to these to rule out the diagnosis has not that the of diagnosing a UTI in females likelihood = of a studies have not been to these with a of but urine were not on all the on H&P UTI, and an probability of a UTI in any of the or symptoms of a The of this systematic review was to determine the operating characteristics specificity, and of H&P and urinalysis for the diagnosis of UTI. that females with symptoms of UTI presenting to an ED a to studies in studies to the ED The and manuscript of this systematic review to the from the of Studies in with a medical two searched the medical literature from January 1965 to October 2012 in PUBMED and EMBASE for the diagnosis and UTIs. Diagnosis was searched laboratory and or UTI was searched history, or The two were and by and For the PUBMED two reviewed the and to potentially relevant which were to the reviewed the for and any were resolved by a The was for any related to UTI. Studies were included female in the ED who with urinary such or Studies were included only urine was the standard for diagnosis. The of the systematic review was to studies that uncomplicated UTIs. studies that included with and infections were and studies on or were not used the Quality Assessment Tool for Diagnostic Accuracy Studies for systematic to the quality of for the quality were by and to by a these two reviewers was assessed a using For the of this diagnostic systematic were a to the quality of individual The be those presenting to an ED with urinary The of and and is by a of or no and no to any that of the for For the standard for UTI was a of colony-forming units in and in included studies used urine the but the standard was not or used a that of was for of the was not that of be for from the included and a resolved any included the standard and diagnostic were to the and of various diagnostic variables history, urine and urine for The and was used to a This is on and specificity, of a diagnostic of and of of these variables were from systematic review to and for ED with UTI. The PUBMED identified the EMBASE identified an additional for a total of the of identified no additional As in a total of diagnostic studies were included in of the reviewed variables and UTI is included in The by was the only the reviewed the of ED suspected of UTIs who had urine over 1 were = and = The of for in the of accounting for a of the reviewed and studies included only female suspected of having UTIs by included to age the studies used an age of 18 This in a for = to a age of years in the that from the age in the by be to that of female and therefore the was The was to but studies that included of 18 years of age were included and For only studies by and and and to The of an in the studies by and and with used an and used an and was the only to with and to any of those with and were the only to with urine dipstick and and and only urine dipstick and not which was used to a positive urine culture. and a UTI by a urine with and used a of UTI. and using a of UTI, not in a prevalence of UTI to UTI to the reviewed of the and the assessment with a of was the and the who any in The quality of the included is in the reviewed have the by to have the of this was the only to a by has that to diagnostic for not that the by from related to and included only medical of females who had urine in to the studies that used of UTI the the not by of a UTI but by having a urine a in the by by only by the of urine have and those with by the This have a the of a diagnostic was in a by who a significantly for urinalysis in diagnosing UTIs in with pretest were by the by in the of their has for to accuracy and in of and of to any of these to from their medical of the of the or tests was only by is that this a of in the the in urine this is a of prevalence of UTI and not of a UTI, not any related to the that of the studies the the and standard had the in the standard of UTI reviewed and used a accepted standard to UTI of and a of a positive a positive any of a of a of UTI. of these the reviewed The related to the accuracy of the outcome to their of urine Only and that were to be negative urine a for urine with cells on urinalysis or with were a for accounting for and are for to than assessed the the of studies identified and in the of The of UTI were and in the studies included in this review. The of infection presenting to the ED are therefore to the of infection in who present to the with symptoms of variables are in with of their diagnostic history of UTI, and in history of and in had the the and the Physical examination variables are in with of their diagnostic > and No single physical examination finding had a than 0.8 or a greater than or variables are in and and all leukocyte esterase and used a of that the reaction the by and the was negative or positive for and used that a range of from to that were by and with a by the reaction was on dipstick present or all and blood which from to and to of and blood reaction had the used positive nitrite had the used in a urinalysis negative for and blood has a of and variables are in used the of urine white blood cells had the and greater than had the and and but bacteriuria and by bacteriuria by of on studies from to The for > was ranging from to the two the operating characteristics of urine than a but not this on of than a was in the > in urinalysis were used in the of or had the The of and > had the The for suspected UTI are symptomatic and the and symptomatic in a for the of uncomplicated UTI. to in a in symptoms and The to is to symptoms and for this of from in with a UTI with to have of symptoms and are to studies used the for confirmed UTI, and was to the of or and in or of and that a of infections The from and were not for an accurate of their small were to or to accurately reflect the and of with with those tests that have or to significantly alter that the pretest probability is for symptomatic a with a of a probability of a with a of a probability of were used to the in an that the LRs in the and to a of and a of using to of and the diagnostic accuracy of nitrite on urine the pretest can be and can be with on the and This systematic review is the to that the utility of H&P and urinalysis for the diagnosis of UTI in the ED The pretest probability of UTI in the ED is a of the utility of these diagnostic that who present to the ED with urinary symptoms be to have UTIs than those who present to the ED is a the prevalence of UTI in the included studies from 40% to that the pretest probability of UTI in who present to the ED with urinary symptoms is to that in studies a prevalence of UTI in the range of who present with symptoms of The by had the prevalence but were included only a urine was which have a have in of the reviewed The by the of to the in its The by have with and the for is not the by has the of and is only in that not were or The included studies the operating characteristics of No single history or examination finding had the to UTI. This is not to that are of no utility in the diagnosis of UTI, the of these variables is to the in the The by had for the of or = that urinary symptoms have a pretest probability for UTI. The by not have a good for but the is by its the operating characteristics of UTI for and the is This is not to be with and that the presenting had a history of UTI and were from the This only be which is that in the a history of UTI was review studies the accuracy of that urinalysis is insufficient to rule in UTI, with the of urine the urine a positive nitrite in the a negative nitrite is not to rule out UTI. No single of the dipstick has the to rule in or out UTI in a with a moderate pretest probability of UTI. of the dipstick the of this but the from the by be not For the of positive for and nitrite the of positive for or the is positive the has or on that will have a and to a that is positive only and nitrite are be to a there are that are the tests positive for and the only has utility it the of who have who positive for to those with the a for the is only useful it with who negative for to those who have the negative the only that are useful to probability are those that for and positive for or nitrite is all the of the the to a single which is that any reaction on dipstick is a positive and a negative urinalysis be useful to rule out Urinalysis is a and an and is on who present with or urinary in the ED. on urinalysis should be to For that the pretest probability of is a with a of such a urine dipstick negative for and will the probability to should not with this but on the or not to a urine culture. If the only of it is to diagnosis. the of and a urine in the of a negative urine dipstick be not than the urine dipstick and should be in The by that the of any has a of which is to a negative urine As with urine a negative urine with urine in the in with a positive urine is not to the of the For the by and = a of for > which to with a pretest probability of 60%. the by was = and the for > was only have been to the urine were and provide the not provide that were and As and by the by pyuria with of disease, and therefore for moderate or > 50 in this is in symptomatic there are no for in the to 50 but the that or not significantly alter probability of UTI. The that the of on urine be an useful of UTI, for and and a for moderate bacteruria and studies the laboratory of the were the two studies had not explain bacteriuria was which for the in Physicians to be in the laboratory bacteriuria in their for of the of the studies the of physical examination, and laboratory in to operating characteristics and should be in a rule on UTI, and on urine the rule not provide and For positive for two out of characteristics was for UTI but only positive for out of was for UTI but not The of or not to a UTI on the in on pretest probability or prevalence of UTI. probability on a pretest probability of using the prevalence from the by in which were on or not had urine a pretest probability of the that any with > should receive which is that is such a a pretest probability of which is to that in not for any on the The of this systematic review is not to physicians to UTI prevalence in their and bedside of probability for urinalysis The are to the and an diagnostic bedside be to in it should not be the on of the the diagnostic of of these moderate or moderate bacteruria to be the predictors of UTI, and be in these used the of for a positive urine will not a this If a urine is in ED for a who not a is in to who are no in the of At and are identified for of and are and are on studies by in the who and urine from with and to those of any that of had greater than to of symptomatic women. this for who have symptoms only of UTI is therefore and has been in who all to a with and urinary and a positive UTI any in urine on participants underwent and and had UTI on that using the of for diagnosis of UTI from have of and that a of should be used for a and of and to only of will have in their and therefore by the standards of the prevalence of confirmed UTI be in any of symptomatic or the with that it has a positive of infection symptomatic symptomatic have pretest to to be is there a and of of At should be The by and used the and in of symptoms and in a in the of symptomatic with for the of uncomplicated UTI in a total of and a is in no in of symptoms no in the of bacteriuria the of was used the standard of The of that is not for and not be all the of infections on their to be that and of physical examination, and urinalysis tests are for UTI diagnosis. tests not used in the ED should be to diagnostic accuracy of UTI. For in = a of and of for the diagnosis of such urine and urine and have for UTI a single is to be accurate and the development of a rule that of history, physical examination, and laboratory tests is to diagnostic accuracy of UTI in the ED. and that with of UTI symptoms not urinalysis and be of this is on the by which that the probability of UTI in who present with urinary and of not urine on all in the its that urinary symptoms are an of but a rule is in not on symptoms the to to the in the and of their UTI diagnostic studies should be a of and physical characteristics and not with UTIs. of to must be in all the of a UTI by studies of and to the development of a rule using such or to the of history, and urinalysis for diagnosing UTIs. Only studies in the were included and only two PUBMED and were is the of ED studies to not uncomplicated UTI in the The in studies range from to years of its applicability to the who often present with is not to the diagnosis of uncomplicated UTI in the and the quality of the is to The by was the for and was = but the only urinalysis and not The studies that urine dipstick and and used making it to the studies that on and and used of the for moderate bacteriuria were the are only from the two studies and and and the of the of in these it to these the The of the in this systematic review for the utility of H&P is not but who are symptomatic for UTI are out with a pretest probability of for of the included are from the by which was to be for the and the only that on H&P is the = and the only that the diagnostic utility of from a history of variables that be with UTI are not included in this systematic such and history of variables an diagnosis such or a history of UTI with be a of UTI and is not in this systematic review. that who had of UTI correctly themselves over of the time, using the for confirmed UTI. The is in that the of and of not is to and used in the are on the by which included only 50 with UTI. The were not sufficiently to of symptoms in the of but no had significantly with from of was in the and the in the in had UTI The by is by the of in the The not the of for the the is to in that the of should be making diagnostic but to be to a accurate of these the in this systematic review are with studies in UTI prevalence and operating characteristics of Urinalysis is but not and to should not be on urinalysis of this systematic can be that presenting to the ED with symptoms of UTI have a pretest probability in the range of Urinalysis with a should emergency physicians on or not is that from with no and it is to for urine the is and an a that no in UTI who those for was a is in to and the of in Patients should be their and the of this review the for the development of a rule or accurate and laboratory for the diagnosis of UTI in the ED. No single or of tests can accurately urinary tract infection in with symptoms for urinary tract infection with moderate pretest the of nitrite in urinary tract The of moderate bacteriuria and/or pyuria on within the urinalysis is a and a rule that of history and laboratory is to diagnostic accuracy of urinary tract infection in the ED. are to the literature of of the Medical
33
Empirical Evidence of Design-Related Bias in Studies of Diagnostic Tests
Jeroen G. Lijmer · JAMA · 1999 · 1.8K citations