Educational research quarterly · 2003 · 18 citations · 0 references
EducationSpecial EducationTeacher EducationDisabilityInclusive EducationSpecial Education PolicyDisability InclusionEducation For Children With DisabilitiesInclusive Classroom EnvironmentsInclusive PracticeInclusive TeachingSpecial Education InclusionInclusive PlacementSelf-contained Classroom PlacementSpecial Education EnvironmentsSpecial Education ProvisionSpecial Education Teacher CollaborationTeacher Attitudes Toward InclusionTeacher Preparation For Inclusion
In this study, perceptions of inclusion students with both mild and severe were explored. Collaboration issues related to inclusion were also examined. Specifically, 180 general education and special education preservice and inservice teachers were given a questionnaire on inclusion. In addition, they were given another questionnaire two weeks later after viewing a videotape of a boy who half teachers were told had a mild disability and half that he had a severe disability. There were no significant differences educational type or experience items that focused on intensity level of including students with mild or severe disabilities. There were significant differences items addressing collaboration issues. After videotape was introduced, there were significant differences both educational type and experience items on intensity of inclusion. Implications of these results were discussed with emphasis on teachers' apparent preference a continuum of services. Since enactment of Public Law 94-142 in 1975, placement models and types of services provided individuals with have been constantly changing. With mandate of least restrictive environment (LRE), a continuum of service delivery models including separate schools, self-contained classrooms, resource rooms, and general education classrooms were made available, based on type and severity of student's disability. Frequently, however, many exceptional students had minimal or no interaction with peers without disabilities. Further, majority of limited interactions often were in nonacademic settings such as bus, lunch room or playground and in nonacademic classes such as art, music, physical education, and industrial arts (Giangreco & Putnam, 1991). However, with school reform efforts such as Regular Education Initiative (REI) in 1980s, students with experienced increased interactions with general education students in academic settings. More recently, concept of full inclusion has received increased support. Full inclusion has been referred to as the provision of appropriate educational services to all students in regular classes attended by non-disabled students of same chronological age in their neighborhood school, including students with severe disabilities (Giangreco & Putnam, 1991, p. 245). This movement has resulted in heated debates with supporters suggesting that denying a student full inclusion is essentially a civil rights violation (Stainback & Stainback, 1992). Critics, on other hand, note that full inclusion is not consistent with LRE and that it places another hardship on general education teachers (Kauffinan & Hallahan, 1995). Chapman (1992) even cautioned, for students with learning difficulties, whose needs have barely been met, inclusion in mainstream seems like exclusion from remedial assistance (p.8). Results of several studies investigating full-inclusive education setting have indicated a positive impact on students with (Bean, Trovato, Zigmond, & Hamilton, 1993; Cannon, Idol, & West, 1992; Pearman, Barnhart, Huang, & Mellblom, 1992; Stainback, Stainback, & Jackson, 1992). Pearman et al. (1992) reported that full-inclusive education model has potential to provide more effective education all students through better coordination among general and special education professionals. Others have reported that full-inclusive settings facilitate students' development of self-esteem, social skills, self-worth, and a sense of pride (Ghose, 1995). Baker, Wang, and Walberg (1994-1995) in a synthesis of existing research, noted a small-to-moderate beneficial effect of inclusive education on academic and social outcomes of special-needs children. In order full inclusion to be effective, however, both general education and special education teachers involved must support it. …