Teacher beliefs and practices: the discipline carries the message

Duba Yaakobi, Shlomo Sharan

Journal of Education for Teaching International Research and Pedagogy · 1985 · 23 citations · 6 references

Concepts

Abstract

Do teachers from different academic disciplines possess different ‘theories of knowledge’ and different attitudes toward education, and are these attitudes related to their classroom practices? Those were the main questions posed in this study in which 142 secondary school teachers from eight schools in the Tel‐Aviv, Israel, area responded to a detailed questionnaire constructed to explore these topics. The responses of teachers of Sciences, Humanities and Languages were compared on 4 scales of progressive versus traditional attitudes and classroom instructional methods, namely: 1. students’ use of varied informational sources for studying academic topics; 2. students’ use of their personal experience for studying and applying academic knowledge; 3. relating given academic material to other disciplines; and 4. teachers’ instructional style (lecture versus experientially orientated learning). Findings indicate that teachers’ views of knowledge, as objective bodies of information or as ideas emerging from personal experience and interpretation, their attitudes toward education and classroom behavior, differed as a function of academic discipline on 3 scales. All teachers concurred on the importance of relating academic knowledge to the students’ life experience. Humanities teachers emerged as the most progressive, language teachers as the least progressive on the three scales, while science teachers were located midway between the other two groups. These results are consistent with Bernstein's theory that academic studies socialize teachers into distinct subgroups that display different orientations toward knowledge and the nature of teaching.

References

6