Is literacy for blind people under threat? Does braille have a future?

TLDR

The introduction of Unified English Braille has sparked concern among braillists, highlighting longstanding issues such as complex symbols, heavy learning demands, limited reading speed, and bulky materials that have historically prompted continuous evolution of the tactile code. The study argues that early and continued braille instruction, particularly in reading speed, is essential to compensate for the lack of unstructured learning and to sustain literacy among blind individuals. Researchers conducted a longitudinal study examining cognitive factors that influence braille reading accuracy, comprehension, and speed. The findings suggest that, contrary to claims of obsolescence, computer technology is making braille more accessible, and its flexibility remains crucial for blind people's independence, requiring educators and professionals to promote literacy through braille.

Abstract

Changes to braille to produce a Unified English Braille (UEB) have caused grave concerns among some braillists. Proponents of UEB claim it will make braille easier to learn and produce and ensure uniformity of practice in the English-speaking world. Section ‘Introduction’ puts the controversy into its wider historical context, citing research showing braille has always been changing. Part A brings out some of braille’s problems in relation to ink-print: quantity and complexity of braille signs, heavier demands on children and newly blind adults in learning their rules of use, the paper-space requirements and bulk of braille books, lower redundancy, lower reading speeds, limited/slower scanning strategies for accessing information, and difficulties with tools for reading and writing. Research is presented from a longitudinal investigation into the cognitive factors affecting the development of braille reading accuracy, comprehension, and speed. Part B argues that there is evidence underlining the need for early teaching to compensate for the absence of casual, unstructured learning available to sighted infants and for continuing the teaching of braille, especially speed of reading, beyond the Primary School Stage of education. It is inferred that contrary to claims that computer technology will render this unique tactile code obsolete, it is in fact making access to braille easier, faster, and cheaper. The code’s flexibility and contribution to the personal, social, and economic independence of blind people are so important that it is vital that teachers, rehabilitation professionals, and psychologists recognise their roles in fostering the attainment of literacy through braille.