Student Evaluations of Faculty Performance: The Role of Gender Expectationis in Differential Evaluations

Marilyn S. Chamberlin, JoAnn S. Hickey

Educational research quarterly · 2001 · 15 citations · 0 references

Concepts

Abstract

Past research has shown how gender contributes to different styles of communication, management, parenting and teaching. Gender roles influence the expectations people have for job performance within various settings. These expectations in turn influence performance evaluations. The purpose of the current study is to identify gendered expectations, holding occupation constant, based on evaluations of instructors' performance in the classroom. Male and female instructors from the same disciplines were evaluated using the same questionnaire. Questions were selected based on gendered expectations. The results of this study indicate that male and female instructors are evaluated differently on aspects of presentation and classroom structure. These findings have implications for promotion and advancement of males and females in traditional gender fields and non traditional gender fields. In addition the results indicate the need to address such differences both within the classroom and within academic institutions. Evaluations of instructors are influenced by many factors. When these evaluations are used to determine promotion, salary and tenure, identification of these factors becomes critical. If evaluation techniques and tools have inherent biases then the decisions based on these tools and techniques will carry similar biases. Ascribed statuses such as race, age, and sex are potential sources for differential evaluations. The focus of this study is to isolate the effect of sex on the course evaluations of faculty by students. SEX OF THE INSTRUCTOR Past research on the influence of the sex of an instructor on evaluations by students has generated conflicting results. Some studies have found no differences between male and female faculty on overall evaluations (Feldman 1993; Dukes and Victoria 1989). Some of the reasons for the lack of general differences can be attributed to methodological factors. Dukes and Victoria (1989) used scenarios rather than actual faculty teaching in front of the students. The students filled in any details that may have been omitted in these scenarios. Even using fictional situations, specific teaching characteristics were found to be influential. Enthusiasm, rapport, knowledge of the material, and organization were all found to influence effectiveness of teaching. The analysis failed to examine the gender differences in these teaching characteristics. Other research has found that these teaching characteristics are related to sex. Female faculty are expected to be warm, friendly (Martin 1984), and encouraging of questions (Feldman 1993). These characteristics form teacher enthusiasm. Characteristics that are related to rapport include being supportive, deferential, and open to others' opinions. These attributes have been identified as expectations or behaviors of female faculty (Feldman 1993; Martin 1984). Male faculty have been rated higher on clarity and knowledge of subject matter (Feldman 1993) and identified by knowledge and organization in Dukes and Victoria (1984). If teaching characteristics reflect gender stereotypes then the differences of sex may be masked by these characteristics. For example a woman is supposed to have better rapport, so the influence of rapport may be a sex difference not a style difference. One study that indicates sex of the instructor may be a mediating factor in style and presentation influences examines course content and sex differences of the instructor when there is student resistance to the topic. Moore (1997) examined how students react to a male instructor presenting feminist views and a female instructor presenting the same views. She found that students described the male as scientific, more objective, more qualified, and less political. The two were presenting the same view in a course on family issues, that included information on gender. Moore's study is primarily anecdotal but provides the basis for a broad analysis of differences in evaluations due to sex of the instructor for similar course content. …