College student journal · 2000 · 41 citations · 0 references
EducationTeacher EducationTeachingClassroom ManagementPedagogyStudent TeachingSpecial Educational NeedsTeacher Professional DevelopmentTeacher-student InteractionTeacher-student RelationshipsStudent-teacher RelationshipsTeacher Perceptions
This paper is an analysis of research on problems experienced by student teachers as they complete student teaching. Findings from ten journal articles and four microfiche documents are categorized according to a model of teacher development based on Frances F. Fuller's (1969) three-stage model of Teacher Concerns: concern with self, with task, and with impact. Five themes of primary concern emerged from the literature. Three are aspects of concern with self: discipline in classroom management, personal and institutional adjustments, and personal characteristics. The other two relate to concerns about managing teaching tasks: teaching methods and strategies, and working with special needs students. None of the concerns of the student teachers had reached the third level of concern, their effect or impact upon students, which was found by Fuller in teachers who had resolved their concerns in the two earlier levels. More than two decades ago, Lock (1977) suggested that more attention be given to the types of concerns student teachers face, which would help to improve the preparation of teachers. A decade later, Doebler and Roberson (1987) wrote that negligible research had been conducted on the perceived problems of student teachers. These assertions still hold true. The study of problems faced by student teachers is important and warranted. The more known about the difficulties which student teachers encounter and the sources of their concerns, the better the chances for eliminating the problems and enhancing every student teacher's chance for success (Doebler & Roberson, 1987; Roberson & Doebler, 1989). In addition, many problems faced by student teachers could possibly be an omen of future conflicts (Briggs & Richardson, 1992). Therefore, the aim of this paper is to analyze the research on problems of student teachers, determine recurring themes, synthesize findings, and categorize them according to an acceptable model of teacher development. There are numerous studies that combine student teachers and beginning teachers as the subjects for study. These two populations, however, are discernibly different. Student teaching is the end product of the teacher education program; it takes place in a public school and is a full-time experience for 10-12 weeks (Guyton & McIntyre, 1990). On the other hand, beginning teachers are those in their first, second, or third full-year of teaching (Veenman, 1984). While the research dealing with beginning teachers has implications for student teachers, this writer concurs with Ryan, Newman, Mager, Applegate, Lasley, Flora, and Johnston (1980). Ryan et al. (1980) who contend that the student teacher's classroom is different from the teacher's classroom. Student teachers are empowered because they have the support and assistance of a master teacher in the classroom; only the best classes are selected for training. Furthermore, student teachers do not have the same degree of legal, professional and ethical responsibility as the teacher (Ryan et al., 1980). Therefore, student teachers' experiences do not closely parallel beginning teachers. According to Watts (1987), most of the research conducted on student teaching fails within one to five categories: student teacher attitudes and personality characteristics, the socialization of student teachers, predictors of success in student teaching, interpersonal relationships in student teaching, and experimental attempts to modify student teacher behaviors. None of Watts' categories focus on the concerns or problems that student teachers encounter. Guyton and McIntyre (1990) declared that some research on student teaching have been of the black box variety. That is, data collected before and after student teaching are compared, without any information about what goes on during student teaching. Hence, this study will explore what takes place during student teaching, problems encountered. …