Concepedia

Reviewer Comments

Reviewer Comments is a scholarly evaluation artifact comprising critical feedback, suggestions, and assessments provided by domain experts on a research proposal, distinguishing it from other forms of academic input through its formal, peer-based, and revision-directed nature.

176

Publications

10K

Citations

481

Authors

285

Institutions

Publications per year

2017–2026

61

Variants

Peer Review CommentsReferee Comments

Parents

Publications

176

ESHRE Guideline: management of women with premature ovarian insufficiency

Lisa Webber, Melanie Davies, Richard A. Anderson et al. · Human Reproduction · 2016 · 1.6K citations · Full text

, , +16

Analysis of the perceived value of online tourism reviews: Influence of readability and reviewer characteristics

Bin Fang, Qiang Ye, Deniz Küçükusta et al. · Tourism Management · 2015 · 599 citations · Full text

, , +15

What Is Method Variance and How Can We Cope With It? A Panel Discussion

Michael Τ. Brannick, David Chan, James M. Conway et al. · Organizational Research Methods · 2010 · 297 citations

, , +16

Peer reviewers learn from giving comments

Young Hoan Cho, Kwangsu Cho · Instructional Science · 2010 · 292 citations

, , +9

Reasons Reviewers Reject and Accept Manuscripts

Georges Bordage · Academic Medicine · 2001 · 231 citations

, , +13

1–5 of 176

Authors

481

  1. CB
    Christian Bird

    Microsoft (United States), United States

    3 publications · 393 citations

    3

    h-index

  2. HD
    Hans‐Dieter Daniel

    ETH Zurich, Switzerland

    3 publications · 125 citations

    3

    h-index

  3. LB
    Lutz Bornmann

    Max Planck Society, Germany

    3 publications · 125 citations

    3

    h-index

  4. PT
    Patanamon Thongtanunam

    The University of Melbourne, Australia

    3 publications · 74 citations

    3

    h-index

  5. AM
    Antonio Mastropaolo

    Università della Svizzera italiana, Switzerland

    2 publications · 195 citations

    2

    h-index

1–5 of 481

Institutions

285

  1. University of Zurich

    Zurich, Switzerland

    6 h-index

    7 publications

    400 citations

  2. University College London

    London, United Kingdom

    5 h-index

    11 publications

    7.9K citations

  3. University of Illinois Chicago

    Chicago, United States

    4 h-index

    5 publications

    411 citations

  4. University of Michigan

    Ann Arbor, United States

    3 h-index

    6 publications

    182 citations

  5. Michigan Medicine

    Ann Arbor, United States

    3 h-index

    6 publications

    180 citations

  6. Stanford University

    Stanford, United States

    3 h-index

    4 publications

    101 citations

  7. ETH Zurich

    Zurich, Switzerland

    3 h-index

    6 publications

    226 citations

  8. University of Massachusetts Amherst

    Amherst Center, United States

    3 h-index

    4 publications

    194 citations

1–8 of 285

Venues

  1. 12

    h-index

  2. Scientometrics

    5 publications · 191 citations

    5

    h-index

  3. IEEE Transactions on Software Engineering

    TSE · 3 publications · 252 citations

    3

    h-index

  4. Research Evaluation

    3 publications · 92 citations

    3

    h-index

  5. Information and Software Technology

    2 publications · 69 citations

    2

    h-index

1–5