Epidemiology
Epidemiology is defined as the study of how diseases and health conditions affect populations, focusing on their origins, spread, and the strategies for mitigating their risks through preventative measures and early interventions. This discipline plays a crucial role in public health by enabling experts to monitor changes in health outcomes across different populations, thereby informing effective health policies and interventions.[15.1]
The field of epidemiology has evolved significantly over time, paralleling the history of public health from ancient civilizations to the present day. It encompasses a wide range of methodologies and applications that have been shaped by historical events and scientific discoveries.[4.1] In contemporary contexts, epidemiology is increasingly intersecting with climate science, as climate epidemiology emerges as a vital area of research. This branch of epidemiology focuses on understanding the impacts of climate change on public health, particularly regarding the emergence and distribution of infectious diseases.[14.1]
The relationship between climate change and infectious diseases is multifaceted, influenced by a range of social and environmental factors, including land use, migration, and vector control. Changes in the prevalence of infectious diseases are not solely a result of climate variables such as temperature and humidity; they also reflect the complex interplay of these social and environmental factors that climate change will impact.[13.1] This evolving landscape necessitates a proactive response from scientists and governments to evaluate the risks associated with the inevitable effects of climate change on epidemics and pandemics. Emergency responses to climate-related disasters should inherently include public health actions aimed at mitigating outbreaks.[12.1]
Epidemiology encompasses several key concepts and terms that are essential for understanding the distribution and determinants of health-related states in populations. At its core, epidemiology is defined as the study of (1) the distribution of health-related states and events in populations, (2) the determinants of these health-related states, and (3) the application of this study to control health problems.[1.1] A fundamental aspect of epidemiology is the measurement of disease outcomes in relation to a population at risk, which includes both healthy and sick individuals who would be counted as cases if they had the disease being studied.[2.1]
The social determinants of health (SDH) are critical non-medical factors that significantly influence health outcomes. These determinants encompass the conditions in which individuals are born, grow, work, live, and age, as well as the broader forces and systems that shape daily life.[7.1] Research indicates that the SDH can have a more profound impact on health than healthcare access or lifestyle choices, underscoring their role in health inequities—unfair and avoidable differences in health status both within and between countries.[7.1] Furthermore, health and health behaviors are shaped by influences at multiple levels, including personal, organizational/institutional, environmental, and policy levels.[6.1] Historically, many health fields have concentrated on individual-level determinants, yet it is essential to recognize how social structures, such as gender and social class, contribute to health disparities by affecting access to knowledge and resources.[6.1] Addressing these social determinants is fundamental for improving health outcomes and reducing longstanding inequities, necessitating action across all sectors and civil society.[7.1]
In addition to social determinants, epidemiology employs various statistical methodologies to analyze health data effectively. For instance, measures such as attack rates, risk ratios (RR), and odds ratios (OR) are commonly used to quantify associations in epidemiological studies.[9.1] The appropriate selection of statistical methods is crucial for accurately interpreting data and addressing specific research questions in public health.[8.1]
The foundations of epidemiology can be traced back to the Greek physician Hippocrates, who is often regarded as the father of medicine. His significant contributions to the field include essential observations on how diseases affected populations and how they spread, as well as addressing issues related to environmental conditions and disease control, particularly concerning water and seasonal changes.[43.1] Additionally, Hippocrates played a crucial role in the establishment of prognosis and clinical observation practices, as well as disease classification, which are fundamental components of modern epidemiology.[44.1] Through these contributions, he laid the groundwork for the methodologies that would later influence the development of epidemiological practices in public health.[43.1]
Following Hippocrates, the 17th century saw the emergence of John Graunt, who is recognized as the world's first epidemiologist and demographer. Graunt utilized the weekly Bills of Mortality, which documented deaths and causes of death in London, to conduct a pioneering analysis that replaced guesswork with reasoned estimates of population sizes and mortality rates.[58.1] His innovative approach provided a quantitative basis for understanding public health issues and marked a significant advancement in the use of statistical methods within epidemiology.[55.1]
The 17th century marked a pivotal moment in the history of science with the discovery of population thinking, which laid the groundwork for all human and social sciences, including epidemiology, demography, and statistics.[56.1] This foundational concept spurred innovative methods, concepts, and institutions in epidemiology, particularly in response to catastrophic pandemics.[53.1] By the 18th century, the tradition of epidemiological study through observation and the use of vital statistics became established in Britain, although the methodological breakthroughs of this period were relatively minor compared to the earlier discovery of population thinking.[53.1] Ultimately, these developments set the stage for more sophisticated statistical approaches that would emerge by the close of the 19th century, transforming the practice of epidemiology.[54.1]
Epidemiology has undergone significant evolution over the centuries, with its foundational concepts traced back to ancient thinkers such as Hippocrates. The discipline has developed through the contributions of key figures, including John Graunt, who is recognized for quantifying vital statistics, and William Farr, who established systematic practices in vital statistics.[37.1] John Snow, often referred to as the father of modern epidemiology, conducted pivotal studies that linked cholera outbreaks to contaminated water sources, marking a transition from supernatural explanations of disease to a scientific understanding based on empirical evidence.[37.1] This historical evolution highlights the critical role of early epidemiologists in shaping the field, illustrating how their foundational work laid the groundwork for contemporary epidemiological practices.
The early 20th century saw the introduction of mathematical methods into epidemiology, notably by Ronald Ross and Anderson Gray McKendrick, which further refined the analytical capabilities of the field.[49.1] The British Doctors Study, published in 1954 by Richard Doll and Austin Bradford Hill, provided robust statistical evidence linking tobacco use to lung cancer, demonstrating the power of epidemiological research in influencing public health policy.[49.1]
As the field progressed, it transitioned from observational studies to incorporating advanced methodologies, including digital epidemiology, which utilizes data visualization tools and online sources for early disease detection.[60.1] The integration of digital technologies has transformed epidemiological practices, allowing for rapid case identification and community transmission prevention through digital contact tracing.[60.1] The COVID-19 pandemic exemplified this evolution, as the swift identification and sequencing of the SARS-CoV-2 virus showcased the advancements in data collection and analysis that have emerged over the past century.[61.1]
Moreover, the reliance on diverse data sets, including electronic medical records and social network data, has expanded the scope of epidemiological research, enabling more comprehensive analyses of health trends and disease outbreaks.[62.1] This evolution reflects a broader trend in public health, where the integration of technology and data science is increasingly vital for addressing contemporary health challenges.[63.1]
Epidemiology utilizes a variety of study designs and methodologies to explore health-related states and events within populations. A key distinction in this field is between clinical trials and observational studies, each possessing unique strengths and limitations. Randomised Controlled Trials (RCTs) are recognized as the cornerstone of Evidence-Based Medicine (EBM) due to their rigorous methodology, which is designed to minimize bias related to confounding factors.[78.1] The major strengths of clinical trials include the investigator's substantial control over the amount of exposure, the timing and frequency of that exposure, and the observation period.[79.1] Additionally, the use of randomization in clinical trials significantly reduces the likelihood that the groups will differ in ways that could affect the outcomes.[79.1] However, while RCTs offer numerous advantages, they also present certain weaknesses that must be acknowledged.[78.1] This level of control enables researchers to draw more definitive conclusions regarding causal relationships between exposures and health outcomes.
In contrast, observational studies, often retrospective, are utilized to assess potential causation in exposure-outcome relationships. These studies are characterized by their ability to measure health outcomes in relation to defined exposures across different groups, facilitating statistical comparisons to identify potential relationships.[87.1] The choice of study design is influenced by various factors, including costs, access to cases, and the specific epidemiologic measures required for the research.[87.1]
Furthermore, community engagement plays a crucial role in epidemiological research, particularly in addressing health disparities. Community-based research principles emphasize collaboration, the integration of knowledge and action, and the empowerment of communities to transcend social inequalities.[105.1] Successful initiatives have demonstrated that co-created public health actions can effectively reduce health inequities and promote social change, highlighting the importance of community participation throughout the research process.[106.1] This participatory approach not only enhances the relevance of the research but also fosters mutual benefits for both researchers and communities involved.
Data collection and analysis in epidemiology are critical for understanding health trends and informing public health interventions. Various statistical methods are employed to analyze epidemiological data, with specific methodologies tailored to different research questions. For instance, cohort studies allow for the estimation of incidence and mortality rates, as well as relative risk (RR) or hazard ratios (HR), which serve as comparative effect measures.[90.1] The significance of regression coefficients is often tested to determine the relationship between explanatory variables and health outcomes, with logistic regression being a common method used to model categorical response variables.[89.1]
In the context of foodborne outbreak investigations, data is typically organized in two-by-two tables, which include measures such as attack rates and risk ratios, facilitating the analysis of associations between food items and illness.[9.1] The integration of real-world data from clinical settings can enhance traditional epidemiological findings by providing insights into the variability observed in larger populations, although challenges remain in ensuring that such data accurately reflects broader health trends.[92.1]
Environmental epidemiology is the application of epidemiological methods to investigate the causes of diseases that are associated with environmental factors (Pearce and Woodward, 2004).[78.1] This field examines how various environmental elements, such as pollutants and climate change, impact health outcomes. A recent World Health Report estimated that 24% of the global disease burden and 23% of all deaths can be attributed to these environmental factors (World Health Organization, 2006).[79.1] Therefore, the systematic collection and analysis of data from diverse sources, including both environmental and social determinants of health, are crucial for informing effective public health interventions and advancing epidemiological research.
The integration of machine learning (ML) and artificial intelligence (AI) techniques in epidemiology has significantly advanced the field, particularly in understanding the complex interplay of biological, social, and environmental factors that influence health outcomes. These technologies enable researchers to model intricate interactions, predict disease risk trajectories, and enhance causal inference methods across various life stages, from gestation to adulthood.[114.1] For instance, ML algorithms have been employed to analyze large genomic datasets, identifying patterns and trends that are crucial for understanding and treating infectious diseases, such as the identification of potential drug targets for SARS-CoV-2, the virus responsible for COVID-19.[116.1]
The integration of big data and artificial intelligence (AI) has significantly transformed the field of epidemiology, providing innovative tools for tracking and predicting the spread of infectious diseases.[115.1] The popular and scholarly press has enthusiastically adopted the term "Big Data" to describe the rapid integration and analysis of large-scale information, although a clear definition remains elusive.[113.1] This advent of big data holds promise for identifying population health intervention targets through the analysis of high-volume and high-variety data.[113.1] Furthermore, it enables the refinement of public health interventions by utilizing high-velocity feedback mechanisms, which can enhance the effectiveness of responses to public health challenges.[113.1] Ultimately, the success of these advancements in epidemiology should be measured by their impact on improving population health outcomes.[113.1]
In life-course epidemiology, the integration of ML and AI offers remarkable opportunities to advance our understanding of health trajectories influenced by various exposures over time. This approach not only aids in identifying sensitive periods for health interventions but also informs the development of more targeted and effective public health strategies.[114.1] As the field continues to evolve, the combination of traditional epidemiological methods with advanced data analytics and machine learning techniques is expected to yield significant improvements in disease prevention and health promotion efforts.
Descriptive studies in epidemiology primarily include cross-sectional studies, which assess both exposures and outcomes at a single point in time, providing a snapshot of a population. This design is particularly useful for determining the prevalence of diseases, phenomena, or opinions within a population, allowing researchers to evaluate outcome differences between exposed and unexposed participants.[180.1] Cross-sectional studies are a vital tool in public health planning, exemplified by national efforts such as the decennial census and the National Health and Nutrition Surveys (NHANES).[181.1] These studies can also track changes in behavioral risk factors, like smoking habits, through sequential cross-sectional designs.[179.1][179.1]
Descriptive epidemiology encompasses various observational study designs, including cross-sectional, case-control, and cohort studies.[145.1] Case-control studies identify study groups based on the outcome and involve the retrospective collection of exposure data of interest.[145.1] These studies are crucial for assessing potential causation in exposure-outcome relationships, which can subsequently influence preventive methods.[148.1] The selection of an appropriate study design should consider factors such as costs, access to cases, identification of the exposure, the required epidemiologic measures, and the level of evidence available regarding the specific exposure-outcome relationship being investigated.[148.1]
Analytic studies in epidemiology are essential for understanding the relationships between exposures and health outcomes. Among the various types of analytic studies, case-control studies, cohort studies, and cross-sectional studies are prominent, each with distinct strengths and limitations that influence their application in public health research.
Case-control studies are observational studies that investigate factors associated with diseases or outcomes by comparing individuals with the condition (cases) to those without it (controls). These studies are particularly useful in identifying potential links and exposures during disease outbreaks, making them a common initial approach for establishing associations between exposures and health events. However, the effectiveness of case-control studies heavily relies on the careful selection of a control group, which is crucial for enhancing the validity of the findings and ensuring accurate correlations between exposures and disease states.[160.1]
Cohort studies, on the other hand, allow researchers to estimate incidence and mortality rates, as well as relative risks or hazard ratios, by following a group of individuals over time. This design is particularly valuable for assessing the cumulative incidence of diseases, as it ensures that all participants are at risk of developing the outcome at the study's outset. For instance, cohort studies have been instrumental in examining the association between hormone replacement therapy and breast cancer, providing critical insights into risk factors and outcomes.[151.1]
Cross-sectional studies are a type of observational study design that allows researchers to measure both exposure and outcome in study participants at a specific point in time, thereby assessing their association. In this design, the investigator does not alter the exposure status but rather observes the existing conditions within the population. While cross-sectional studies can be efficient and cost-effective, they have limitations in establishing causality due to their inability to track changes over time. This limitation is also present in other observational study designs, such as case-control studies, which similarly focus on existing conditions without manipulating exposure status.[159.1]
Environmental epidemiology identifies various environmental exposures that can serve as risk factors for disease, illness, and injury. This field examines how external risk factors, such as air and water pollution, toxic chemicals, and physical hazards, influence human health outcomes.[188.1] Research in environmental epidemiology often employs biostatistical methods to quantify the relationships between these exposures and health outcomes, thereby informing public health policies and risk management strategies.[187.1]
Air pollution poses a major threat to global health, with the World Health Organization (WHO) reporting that approximately 4.2 million people die each year due to poor air quality, predominantly affecting individuals in low- and middle-income countries, where 91% of these deaths occur.[199.1] The WHO identifies air pollution and climate change as the leading threats to human health, contributing to 9% of all global deaths.[201.1] The health impacts of air pollution are extensive, leading to various conditions, including ischemic heart disease, cerebrovascular disease, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, and acute lower respiratory infections.[201.1] Furthermore, household air pollution significantly affects vulnerable populations, particularly women and young children, who are at greater risk due to prolonged indoor exposure.[200.1]
The understanding of the health effects associated with air pollution has significantly advanced over the past few decades. Research has shown that air pollutants, such as ozone and particulate matter (PM), increase the severity of lung and heart diseases, as well as other health problems.[202.1] A multidisciplinary approach, which includes epidemiology, animal toxicology, and controlled human exposure studies, has been crucial in elucidating the actions, exposure-response characteristics, and mechanisms of action of these common air pollutants.[203.1] Despite these advancements, further investigation is necessary to fully understand the detrimental effects of poor air quality, particularly in vulnerable populations.[202.1] This ongoing research is vital for estimating the additional burden of health outcomes associated with climate change and for identifying the most suitable public health interventions to address the identified health impacts of greatest concern.[198.1]
As climate change continues to pose significant challenges to public health, the role of environmental epidemiology is evolving. The 2015 Lancet Commission on Health and Climate Change emphasized the need for comprehensive policy responses to address the health impacts of climate change, highlighting the importance of interdisciplinary collaboration in this field.[196.1] Programs such as the CDC's Climate and Health Program are actively working to prepare public health agencies for the health impacts associated with climate change, further underscoring the critical role of environmental epidemiology in disease prevention and health promotion.[197.1]
Environmental epidemiology encompasses various study designs aimed at understanding the relationship between environmental exposures and health outcomes. These studies often utilize a range of analytic techniques to assess how external risk factors may influence disease, illness, or injury. A significant challenge in this field is the difficulty of studying small populations or rare diseases, which can complicate the interpretation of data and the establishment of causal relationships.[189.1]
Epidemiologists typically evaluate existing data sources, such as vital statistics, disease registries, and healthcare records, to determine their relevance and accuracy for specific investigation objectives. This evaluation is crucial for ensuring that the data collected is reliable and can effectively address the research questions posed.[190.1] Additionally, the integration of field response data collection with existing surveillance systems has become increasingly common, enhancing the efficiency and timeliness of data management during investigations.[191.1]
Research in environmental epidemiology often focuses on identifying associations between environmental contaminants and adverse health outcomes. For instance, studies have established links between exposure to pollutants in air, water, or food and various health issues, including respiratory diseases and developmental abnormalities.[192.1] However, detecting these relationships can be challenging, particularly when the increase in disease incidence due to environmental exposure is modest, necessitating large sample sizes to achieve statistical significance.[193.1]
Moreover, emerging research has begun to explore the connections between environmental exposures and mental health outcomes. This area of study highlights the importance of considering a broad range of environmental stressors, including chemical, biological, and physical factors, in understanding their impact on mental and behavioral health.[194.1] As the field evolves, integrating mental health considerations into environmental health assessments is becoming increasingly recognized as essential for comprehensive public health strategies.
Epidemiology has been shaped by numerous influential figures whose pioneering work laid the foundation for modern public health practices. Among these, John Snow (1813–1858) is often regarded as the father of contemporary epidemiology. His groundbreaking studies during the cholera outbreaks in London, particularly his investigation of the Broad Street pump in 1854, demonstrated the importance of data-driven decision-making and scientific rigor in understanding disease transmission. Snow's "Grand Experiment," which compared cholera cases in areas with contaminated versus clean water, was pivotal in establishing the link between water quality and disease spread, fundamentally transforming public health practices.[231.1]
Another significant figure is William Farr (1807–1883), an English epidemiologist who utilized statistical methods to study medical issues. Farr developed a system for recording causes of death and monitoring disease outbreaks, which has had a lasting impact on public health policy and the interpretation of health data. His contributions to the field of epidemiology emphasized the necessity of accurate data collection and analysis in improving health outcomes.[225.1]
The field of epidemiology has been significantly shaped by several key historical figures. Hippocrates (460 B.C.–377 B.C.) is recognized as one of the earliest contributors to epidemiological thought, as he was an ancient Greek physician whose work laid foundational concepts in the understanding of disease.[224.1] His observations have been crucial in the development of early medical practices. Another pivotal figure, John Snow, conducted groundbreaking research during the cholera outbreak in the mid-1800s, which laid the foundation for modern epidemiology.[223.1] His work demonstrated the vital role that epidemiologists play in understanding disease patterns and prevention, ultimately transforming public health policies and practices.[223.1] Additionally, Françoise Barré-Sinoussi, who shared the Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine in 2008 for her work on retroviruses, including HIV, has made significant contributions to the field of epidemiology.[224.1]
The legacy of these early epidemiologists continues to influence current public health practices, underscoring the importance of statistical methods and rigorous research in addressing today's health challenges.[230.1]
Contemporary epidemiology has been significantly shaped by the foundational work of historical figures, whose methodologies and insights continue to inform modern practices. For instance, William Farr's pioneering contributions to the collection and interpretation of health data laid the groundwork for contemporary public health policies. His innovative use of statistics to study medical issues and develop a system for recording causes of death has established him as a key figure in the evolution of surveillance methods in epidemiology.[247.1]
John Snow, an English physician, is often recognized as a pivotal figure in the development of modern epidemiology due to his innovative methods, which included the use of spatial analysis and statistical mapping. These meticulous techniques challenged prevailing theories of disease transmission and laid the groundwork for contemporary public health initiatives.[249.1] His groundbreaking work in cholera epidemiology not only transformed the understanding of disease spread but also established principles that continue to influence public health practices worldwide.[247.1] Furthermore, the contributions of early epidemiologists like Snow and William Farr have significantly shaped public health policy by advocating for evidence-based approaches, ensuring that health policies are grounded in rigorous scientific research.[236.1] The legacy of these figures is evident in the ongoing emphasis on accurate data collection and analysis, which is essential for developing effective public health strategies that improve community health.[247.1]
In recent years, the integration of machine learning (ML) and artificial intelligence (AI) techniques has significantly transformed the field of epidemiology, particularly in life-course epidemiology. These technologies offer remarkable opportunities to advance our understanding of the complex interplay between biological, social, and environmental factors that shape health trajectories across the lifespan, enabling researchers to identify sensitive periods and model complex interactions.[239.1] Furthermore, AI and ML can analyze large datasets, such as genomic data, to identify patterns and trends relevant to infectious diseases, as well as predict the likelihood of certain outcomes based on historical data.[240.1] The impact of big data on public health epidemiology is profound, contributing to more efficient surveillance and personalized health interventions, which enhances policy decisions.[241.1] Additionally, big data epidemiology plays a crucial role in pandemic response by providing data-driven insights that utilize tools differing from traditional methods, although challenges such as data quality and accessibility remain.[242.1]
Epidemiology plays a foundational role in the development of public health policies, guiding decision-making processes through the analysis of health data and trends. It informs health care clients, professionals, and public health practitioners, including nurses, who rely on sound epidemiological studies to make informed health care decisions and health education initiatives.[267.1] The integration of epidemiological data into public policy is essential for effective disease control and prevention strategies, as evidenced by various successful interventions that have been implemented across different sectors.
The Community Partners in Care (CPIC) initiative serves as a significant example of a collaborative care study focused on addressing depression through 95 programs across various sectors, including outpatient primary care, outpatient mental health, substance use treatment services, homeless services, and other community services such as senior centers and churches.[269.1] This initiative underscores the importance of understanding and integrating public health principles, which are vital for the success and longevity of community mental health initiatives.[270.1] Effective community interventions informed by epidemiological studies include international lay health worker programs, parenting interventions aimed at reducing child abuse, whole-school cognitive behavioral therapy prevention programs, adapted Assertive Community Treatment (ACT) teams for early psychosis and justice-involved populations, Housing First services, and multi-sector collaborative care and prevention services.[269.1] These examples illustrate how prevention programs within communities can mitigate risk factors associated with mental health challenges and promote resilience among individuals.[270.1]
The integration of real-time epidemiological data has significantly enhanced the responsiveness of health policies during public health emergencies, such as the COVID-19 pandemic. A primary advancement in this area is the development of decision-making dashboards that utilize global digital citizen science, which allows for real-time data analytics to inform public health responses.[271.1] However, challenges in public health data management persist, undermining the ability to make informed decisions, particularly in resource-limited settings where access to accurate and timely data may be restricted.[275.1] Longstanding issues in the management of public health data have been identified, which hinder the nation's capacity to respond swiftly to emergencies like COVID-19 and monkeypox.[272.1] To address these challenges, it is recommended that the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) establish an expert committee to develop data collection and reporting standards by engaging with stakeholders from both public and private sectors.[272.1]
Epidemiology is a vital field in public health, but it faces several limitations that can significantly affect the interpretation of data and the conclusions drawn from studies. One major challenge is the distinction between causation and correlation, which can complicate the decision-making process for policymakers.[276.1] Additionally, data limitations can hinder the ability to make informed decisions, particularly in resource-limited settings where access to accurate and timely data may be restricted.[275.1] Furthermore, the methods by which data are presented to the public often differ significantly among data-sharing institutions, such as public health departments and ministries of health. Many of these institutions operate under resource constraints and rely on older websites that typically release data in either common formats (e.g., CSV, Microsoft Excel, PDF) or HTML tables.[277.1] These inconsistencies in data presentation can further complicate the effective use of epidemiological data in shaping public health policy.
Epidemiology plays a crucial role in shaping community health strategies by addressing various public health concerns beyond mere disease transmission. It provides a scientific basis for understanding health behaviors and interactions within populations, which is essential for developing effective interventions. For instance, observational studies in epidemiology allow researchers to directly observe subjects, thereby gaining insights into behaviors that influence health outcomes, including mental health conditions and their associated risk factors.[259.1]
One significant aspect of community health strategies is the focus on social determinants of health. The integration of epidemiological data with mental health research can enhance our understanding of how social factors influence mental health outcomes. This integration can guide the development of preventive strategies that address inequalities and improve population mental health.[279.1] Community health workers (CHWs) have been instrumental in implementing interventions that target these social determinants, improving patient engagement and treatment utilization, particularly in low-resource settings.[280.1] Future research is encouraged to explore multi-domain interventions that consider an individual's social position and living circumstances, which may yield better health outcomes for those with mental health conditions.[280.1]
Additionally, community-based interventions that foster social capital—such as building connections among refugees—have shown promise in reducing mental health symptoms. These interventions highlight the importance of addressing social determinants within community settings, advocating for broader transdiagnostic prevention solutions that can be integrated into schools and communities.[281.1] By focusing on these strategies, epidemiology not only aids in disease control but also promotes health equity and enhances the overall well-being of communities.
114
bmcmedicine.biomedcentral.com
239
bmcmedicine.biomedcentral.com