“A Strong Man Is Direct and a Direct Woman Is a Bitch”: Gendered Discourses and Their Influence on Employment Roles in Sport Organizations

Sally Shaw, Larena Hoeber

Journal of Sport Management · 2003 · 201 citations · 36 references

Concepts

TL;DR

Although more women have entered senior sport management over the past three decades, men remain the dominant group, reflecting persistent gender inequity and the assumption that women fit lower‑level roles while men fit senior positions. The study seeks to examine how dominant discourses shape perceptions of men’s and women’s managerial abilities and influence employment roles within sport organizations. Analysis of documents and interviews revealed that masculine discourses dominate senior positions, while feminine discourses are linked to undervalued roles, though resistance to these norms is possible and discussed in the context of an organization’s commitment to change.

Abstract

Despite increasing numbers of women in senior sport management positions over the past 30 years, men still remain dominant in these roles, indicating a level of gender inequity within sport management. It is often assumed within sport organizations that women are well-matched for lower level management roles, whereas men are more suited to senior management roles. In order to understand perceptions held about women's and men's abilities related to sport management, it is necessary to understand and then analyze discourses, or dominant forms of knowledge, that influence various employment roles in sport organizations. After analyzing organizational documents and transcripts from interviews with 35 employees from three national sport organizations in England, it was found that senior management roles were heavily dominated by discourses of masculinity that are linked to men and are highly valued in sport organizations. In contrast, women and discourses of femininity are associated with employment roles that are undervalued within organizations. There is, however, the potential for resistance to these discourses on a number of levels and this is discussed with relation to one organization's commitment to change “taken for granted” assumptions about gendered employment roles in sport management.

References

36