Medically Useful Criteria for Analytic Performance of Laboratory Tests

Laurence P. Skendzel, Roy N. Barnett, R.B. Platt

American Journal of Clinical Pathology · 1985 · 132 citations · 6 references

Concepts

TL;DR

The study aimed to develop medically useful guidelines for analytic precision of common clinical laboratory tests by surveying randomly selected physicians. Physicians were surveyed to identify the magnitude of test result changes that would influence diagnosis or treatment, and the resulting precision targets were calculated and compared with current laboratory performance. Nearly all examined laboratory procedures met the derived precision targets, and the authors concluded that future improvements in clinical testing will rely on factors beyond analytic precision.

Abstract

To establish medically useful guidelines for analytic precision of commonly used clinical laboratory procedures, the authors conducted a mail survey of physicians selected randomly from national lists of specialists. They were asked to review, briefly, outlined clinical problems and select the change in test results that would alter their diagnosis or treatment or prompt further assessment of the patient's condition. The responses were used to calculate goals for laboratory precision that are sufficient to meet the present requirements of the average physician. The medically useful limits were compared with existing performance of laboratories as reported in national proficiency surveys and regional quality control programs. Almost all the common laboratory procedures they studied are being assayed at a precision level adequate for the perceived needs. The authors suggest that, for the more common constituents, further progress in clinical laboratory testing will depend on factors other than the improvement of analytic precision.

References

6