On the Importance of African-American Faculty in Higher Education: Implications and Recommendations.

Leslie D. Gonzales, Elizabeth T. Murakami, Anne‐Marie Núñez

Educational foundations · 2013 · 46 citations · 0 references

Concepts

Abstract

Introduction This paper focuses on the presence and experiences of Latina (1) academics in the U.S., especially those who serve in Hispanic Serving Institutions (HSIs). Following the theme of this special issue related to Women of Color Faculty's Testimonios and Laberintos, we add to the notion of academia as a labyrinth (laberinto), suggesting that it is a pathway with many twists and turns, each of which presents an opportunity, a possibility, and of course, a responsibility. Based on a review of literature and a fresh analysis of some of our previous work, we employ critical neo-institutional (CNI) and intersectionality theories to examine the experiences of Latinas as they navigate this labyrinth. We begin from the perspective that the post-secondary field and academic careers unfold in spaces where relations of power are always converging, and where naming and sketching out legitimacy is at the core of these power relations. To this end, we selected CNI and intersectionality lenses to help us analyze the experiences of Latinas in academia because each of these theories consider legitimacy a crucial resource in the higher education field: a resource for which academics are constantly struggling towards (Collins, 1986; Delgado-Bernal & Villalpando, 2002; Gonzales, 2012a; Stanley, 2007) and an ascription for which post-secondary institutions are constantly jockeying (Gonzales, 2013a; Morphew, 2009; Pusser & Marginson, 2012; Toma, 2012; Tuchman, 2009). To illustrate Latina faculty in the academic laberinto, we move between these theoretical lenses and the literature to highlight the experiences, opportunities, and implications for Latinas serving in academia. We begin by describing our theoretical lenses, alluding from time to time, as to how they apply to the experiences of Latina faculty members in academia. Then, we present a review of research that documents the pathways on which Latinas begin their journey into the professoriate, and studies, many of which are testimonios, that point out how relations of power are always at work. Our intent is to showcase how these relations of power play out at the organizational level and at the individual level in particular ways for Latina professors. Ultimately, we suggest there are unique opportunities as well as implications for Latina women who occupy multiple marginalities (Turner, 2003). Situating the Experiences: Theoretical lenses to observe El Laberinto y Los Testimonios We situate the experiences of Latina faculty through two theoretical frameworks: critical neoinstitutionalism and intersectionality. Critical neo-institutionalism (CNI) was developed as a direct response to the overtly positivistic and scientific conception of organizational phenomena and recognizes the cultural and social relations that shape organizational fields, like higher education (Cooper, Ezzamel, & Willmott, 2008; Meyer & Rowan, 1977; Phillips & Malhotra, 2008; Powell & DiMaggio, 1991). With CNI, we are able to more precisely sketch out the field of higher education and highlight the power relations that maintain hierarchy and difference (Gonzales, 2013a; Morphew, 2009; Pusser & Marginson, 2012; Toma, 2012). In this way, it helps us reveal the walls of the laberinto Latina faculty and other women faculty of color must traverse. Intersectionality, on the other hand, is a perspective that stems from the traditions of critical race theory (CRT), its variants, and feminist perspectives (Crenshaw, 1989; Collins, 1986; Davis, 2008). Intersectionality helps us understand the journey of Latina faculty within the laberinto (Nunez & Murakami-Ramalho, 2011). The journeys, most efficaciously shared through testimonios (testimonies) show that individuals embody facets of identity (e.g., gender, race, tenure status, marital status, sexuality) simultaneously (Hankivsky et ah, 2010; Holvino, 2008; McCall, 2005; Oleksy, 2011) and that these facets are always intersecting with different arenas of investigation (Anthias, 2013, p. …