The Relationship of Transactional and Transformational Leadership to the Organizational Effectiveness of Dutch National Sport Organizations

G.H.J. Pruijn, Robert Boucher

European journal for sport management. · 1995 · 17 citations · 0 references

Concepts

Abstract

The purpose of this study was to determine the relationship of transactional and transformational leadership to the organizational effectiveness of Dutch National Sport Organizations (DNSO). In effect, the applicability of Bass4 (1985) Transformational Leadership Theory was tested in the sport environment of The Netherlands. Bass (1991) suggested that there are universal principles in transformational leadership which apply across cultures, yet the majority of previous research results are derived from the North American setting.To collect information about leadership, the Multifactor Leadership Questionnaire (MLQ) was used, both the Self and the Rater versions. Organizational effectiveness was considered to be the dependent variable and data were collected using the Organizational Effectiveness Questionnaire (OEQ). The response rate for returned questionnaires was 94.25%.Most results regarding the main hypothesis dealing with the influence of transformational leadership on organizational effectiveness were not significant and these findings led the researchers to fail to reject the null hypothesis. Six sub hypotheses were developed to test the influence of six leadership factors. Only two significant outcomes were found in 42 manipulations of the data and therefore the null hypotheses for each leadership factor could not be rejected.In addition to the analyses of variance, Tukey’s Honestly Significant Difference (HSD) test was used to determine exactly where the difference between groups existed. The test uncovered that medium transformational leaders were more effective than high transformational leaders.The results of this study do not provide general support for Bass4 (1991) argument that transformational leadership is universally applicable. Studying these factors in the Dutch sport setting with its specific characteristics, might have prevented the researchers from supporting the results of previous investigators.