A Comparison of Accuracy and Cost of LiDAR versus Stand Exam Data for Landscape Management on the Malheur National Forest

Susan Hummel, Andrew T. Hudak, Edward H. Uebler, M. J. Falkowski, Kevin Megown

Journal of Forestry · 2011 · 135 citations · 15 references

DOIFull text

Open access

Concepts

TL;DR

Foresters increasingly rely on remote sensing because it offers landscape overviews impractical with field samples alone, yet LiDAR’s exceptional spatial detail is hampered by processing challenges and high data‑collection costs. The study aimed to compare stand‑level LiDAR and Landsat predictions of structural and volume attributes with traditional stand exams and to evaluate their relative costs. We generated stand‑level summaries from LiDAR and Landsat data and assessed their costs relative to conventional stand exams. LiDAR‑based stand inventories were as accurate and cost‑effective as traditional stand exams for structural attributes, yet they covered a far larger area.

Abstract

Abstract Foresters are increasingly interested in remote sensing data because they provide an overview of landscape conditions, which is impractical with field sample data alone. Light Detection and Ranging (LiDAR) provides exceptional spatial detail of forest structure, but difficulties in processing LiDAR data have limited their application beyond the research community. Another obstacle to operational use of LiDAR data has been the high cost of data collection. Our objectives in this study were to summarize, at the stand level, both LiDAR- and Landsat (satellite)-based predictions of some common structural and volume attributes and to compare the cost of obtaining such summaries with those obtained through traditional stand exams. We found that the accuracy and cost of a LiDAR-based inventory summarized at the stand level was comparable to traditional stand exams for structural attributes. However, the LiDAR data were able to provide information across a much larger area than the stand exams alone.

References

15