Journal of managerial issues · 2003 · 29 citations · 9 references
BusinessAccountancyAccountingAccounting EthicsAuditingBusiness EthicsFinancial ReportingProfessional Ethics In AuditingAccounting JudgmentsEthical Decision-making In AccountingEthical Decision-making In AuditingEthical Judgment In AccountingProfessional Ethics In Accounting
Recent headlines highlight the increased attention placed on the values and ethics of business professionals and accountants. In 2001, the implications of Enron were not limited to the business press and accounting journals. Rather, accounting practitioners and business managers have been brought to the front page of newspapers and have been continuously paraded on the evening news of television networks (e.g., Byrnes, 2002; Liesman, 2002; White, 2002). In 2002, Securities and Exchange Chairman Harvey Pitt as well as Congress expressed the potential need to substantially modify the entire system of financial reporting. In particular, the profession has found itself in a crisis related to the long-standing system of serf-governance through private rather than public organizations. In an attempt to head off some of these concerns, the Big Five have preemptively volunteered to change a substantial portion of their business practice. They might no longer provide consulting services to current audit clients. The once envious and untarnished reputation of accountants as independent, objective, reliable, honest watchdogs is being called into question. Considering these events, we believe it is fruitful to study the personal values of accounting graduates and to learn how they might differ by gender and by age. Personal values are important to study because they provide the foundation for behavior. Past research in a variety of disciplines over the last twenty years (Baker, 1976; England, 1975; Finegan, 1994; Fritzsche, 1995; Rokeach, 1973; Singhapakdi and Vitell, 1993) provides evidence that one's personal values influence behavior, including managerial and corporate strategy decisions. Recent research as well as current business trends provide additional support for the positive correlation between values and behavior. Burdett (1998) holds that when the personal values of individuals are matched properly with those of the firm, the organization displays more effective behavior. A similar view is espoused by Erode (1998), which supports an alignment between personal and corporate values. Many businesses are putting these ideas into practice. Even before Enron, most corporations as well as accounting firms had expressed an increased interest in ethical awareness and many have developed codes of conduct (Ahadiat and Smith, 1994; Benson, 1989). Statement on Auditing Standards (SAS) No. 78 has been issued for auditors to gain an understanding of ethical values. Two early studies examined the personal values of accountants. Swindle et al. (1987) found that CPAs were more focused on their own personal goals rather than others. Pinac-Ward et al. (1995) found similar results for accounting educators. However, neither of these studies provided a systematic classification of the value systems of accountants. Examining business students, Eaton and Giacomino (2001, 2000) found that accounting majors were more likely than non-accounting majors to use moral means to accomplish their personal goals. They also found differences between genders. Females were more likely to focus on larger organizational goals compared to individual, personal goals. Other accounting studies have examined gender differences in other contexts and found that women have higher moral development (Sweeney, 1995) and are more likely to view questionable behavior to be unethical (Cohen et al., 1998) than males. But these studies have not addressed personal values. The primary goal of this study is to gather empirical evidence to develop a better understanding of the personal values of accounting graduates. Second, we also explore differences in personal values by gender and age. These demographic variables have changed in recent years. For example, the percentages of females in business and in accounting have increased, as firms have made substantial efforts to recruit and retain women. Third, we want to compare the results of this study with previous studies on personal values of other business professionals and students. …
9