Health Promotion International · 2024 · 11 citations · 43 references
Public AffairsHealth PolicyPublic PolicyHealth Policy AnalysisPolicy AnalysisPublic Health PolicyPolicy DesignPolicy DevelopmentPublic-private Partnerships In HealthTobacco Industry InfluenceTobacco PolicyCausal Loop AnalysisCausal Loop Diagram ConstructionCausal Loop Diagram InterpretationCausal Loop ModelingHealth Policy DevelopmentIndustry Influence On RegulationPolicy Formulation ProcessUltra-processed Food Policy
Unhealthy commodity industries (UCIs) such as tobacco, alcohol, gambling, ultra-processed food and beverage producers are known to influence policy-making to advance their interests, often to the detriment of public health goals. This study mapped the complex system underpinning UCI's influence on public health policy formulation in the UK and identified potential interventions to shift the system towards being able to better attain public health goals. We conducted a participatory systems mapping workshop with ten experts to build a causal loop diagram (CLD) and identify potential interventions to address UCI's influence on public health policy development. The resulting CLD depicts a highly interconnected and reinforcing system driving UCI's involvement in public health policy formulation across five thematic areas. Among the most connected elements were the 'dominance of market mechanisms', 'perception of partnership as good governance principle', 'industry involvement lending perceived legitimacy to the policy formulation process', 'industry is seen as part of the solution' and 'industry ties to policy-makers'. Participants identified a total of 22 interventions within this system. Analysis of the CLD and interventions identified the potential for two key paradigmatic changes in this complex system: de-normalizing the perception of unhealthy commodity industry actors as legitimate stakeholders in policy formulation; and prioritizing public health and wellbeing objectives over profit and economic gain. In order to shift the system towards better attaining public health goals, interventions should reinforce each other and be supportive of these two key paradigmatic shifts.
43
The need for a complex systems model of evidence for public health
Harry Rutter, Natalie Savona, Ketevan Glonti et al. · The Lancet · 2017 · 1.3K citations · Full text
Wellbeing economy: An effective paradigm to mainstream post-growth policies?
Lorenzo Fioramonti, Luca Coscieme, Robert Costanza et al. · Ecological Economics · 2021 · 189 citations · Full text
Systems change for the social determinants of health
Gemma Carey, Brad Crammond · BMC Public Health · 2015 · 175 citations · Full text