Legislation restricting gender-affirming care for transgender youth: Politics eclipse healthcare

Katherine L. Kraschel, Alexander Chen, Jack L. Turban, I. Glenn Cohen

Cell Reports Medicine · 2022 · 68 citations · 7 references

DOIFull text

Open access

Concepts

Abstract

In the past two years, in 25 US states, bills have been introduced to restrict access to gender-affirming medical care for minors. Some have already become law. We show how these bills, while purporting to “protect” trans youth, are really an assault on their ability, along with their parents’ and physicians’, to make healthcare choices and to receive medically necessary care. We discuss the evidence-based guidelines for the care of these patients, the positions taken by major medical societies against these bills, and the landscape of legal challenges that are being brought against these enacted laws. In the past two years, in 25 US states, bills have been introduced to restrict access to gender-affirming medical care for minors. Some have already become law. We show how these bills, while purporting to “protect” trans youth, are really an assault on their ability, along with their parents’ and physicians’, to make healthcare choices and to receive medically necessary care. We discuss the evidence-based guidelines for the care of these patients, the positions taken by major medical societies against these bills, and the landscape of legal challenges that are being brought against these enacted laws. Legislators in 25 US states have introduced bills to restrict access to gender-affirming medical care for minors in the past two years (Table 1). To date, these bills have become law in Alabama, Arkansas, and Arizona. On their face, these efforts claim to “protect” trans (we use the terms “trans” and “transgender” interchangeably) youth. However, as we discuss in this commentary, far from helping trans youth, these laws prevent them from receiving medically necessary care that learned professional societies have established. For this reason, relevant professional organizations including The American Medical Association, The American Academy of Pediatrics, The American Psychiatric Association, and The American Academy of Child & Adolescent Psychiatry have explicitly voiced opposition to these laws.1Turban J.L. Kraschel K.L. Cohen I.G. Legislation to criminalize gender-affirming medical care for transgender youth.JAMA. 2021; 325: 2251https://doi.org/10.1001/jama.2021.7764Crossref PubMed Scopus (36) Google Scholar These proposed bills and laws share common flaws—they are based on false claims about standards of care and health outcomes for people with gender dysphoria, and they are based on inaccurate, biased, and misleading representations of the evidence base.2Boulware S.D. Kamody R. Kuper L. McNamara M. Olezeski C. Szilagyi N. Alstott A. Biased Science: The Texas and Alabama Measures Criminalizing Medical Treatment for Transgender Children and Adolescents Rely on Inaccurate and Misleading Scientific Claims.https://medicine.yale.edu/childstudy/policy-and-social-innovation/lgbtq-youth/report%20on%20the%20science%20of%20gender-affirming%20care%20final%20april%2028%202022_437080_54636_v2.pdfDate: 2022Google ScholarTable 1Proposed state bills and laws to limit access to gender-affirming medical care for transgender adolescents in 2021 and 2022Statebill and brief summary of some major provisionsAlabamaHB1/SB10 (2021)/HB266/SB184 (enacted 2022): Criminalizes the provision of some gender-affirming medical or surgical care to transgender adolescents and requires school personnel to reveal the gender identity of transgender youth to their parents.ArizonaSB1511 (2021): Adds some gender-affirming medical and surgical care to the state’s definition of child abuse and criminalizes physician activity of this sort.SB1138 (enacted 2022): Prohibits the provision of gender-affirming surgical care to transgender minors.ArkansasHB1570/SB347 (enacted 2021): Prohibits the provision of some gender-affirming medical or surgical care to transgender adolescents and prohibits the use of public funds for gender-affirming care. Recently became law when the state legislature overrode the Governor’s veto.FloridaHB935 (2021)/HB211(2022): Criminalizes the provision of some gender-affirming medical and surgical care to transgender adolescents.GeorgiaHB401 (2021): Criminalizes the provision of gender-affirming medical and surgical care to transgender adolescents. Creates civil claim against medical professionals who provide gender-affirming care to transgender minors.IdahoHB675 (2022): Criminalizes the provision of gender-affirming medical care to transgender adolescents. Adds gender-affirming medical care to the definition of genital mutilation of a child.IndianaSB224 (2021): Prohibits the provision of gender-affirming surgical and medical care to transgender minors.IowaHF193 (2021): Subjects health professionals to civil liability and disciplinary sanction for the provision of some gender-affirming medical and surgical care to transgender adolescents.KansasHB2210 (2021): Criminalizes the provision of some gender-affirming medical or surgical care to transgender adolescents.KentuckyHB253/SB84 (2022): Subjects health professionals to civil liability and disciplinary sanction for the provision of some gender-affirming medical and surgical care to transgender adolescents. Prohibits the use of public funds for gender-affirming care to minors.LouisianaHB575 (2021)/HB570 (2022): Criminalizes the provision of some gender-affirming medical or surgical care to transgender adolescents. Prohibits school personnel to withhold from parents or legal guardians “information related to a minor’s gender or sex that is inconsistent with the minor’s sex.” Creates civil liability for providers and parents in violation. Prohibits the use of public funds for gender-affirming care to minors.MississippiHB1147 (2022)/SB2728 (2022): Prohibits provision of or referral for gender-affirming surgical and medical care to transgender minors. Prohibits the use of public funds for any gender-affirming medical care to transgender minors.MissouriHB33 (2021): Subjects medical professionals who provide some gender-affirming medical or surgical care to transgender adolescents to possibility of healthcare license revocation. Establishes that parents or guardians who obtain some gender-affirming medical or surgical care for transgender adolescents shall be reported to the state’s child welfare division.HB2649 (2022): Subjects medical professionals who provide some gender-affirming medical or surgical care to transgender adolescents to possibility of healthcare license revocation. Disallows public funds to any organization or individual who provides gender-affirming care to transgender minors. Creates civil claim against medical professionals who provide gender-affirming care to transgender minors.MontanaHB 427 (2021): Prohibits the provision of gender-affirming surgical and medical care to transgender minors.New HampshireHB68 (2021): Criminalizes the provision of gender-affirming healthcare to transgender minors.North CarolinaSB514 (2021): Subjects medical professionals who provide some gender-affirming medical or surgical care to transgender adolescents to having their healthcare license revoked and authorizes civil liability. Prohibits use of public funds for gender-affirming care. Requires government employees to reveal the gender identity of transgender youth to their parents in writing. Prohibits the use of public funds for gender-affirming medical or surgical care.OhioHB 454 (2021): Prohibits the provision of gender-affirming surgical and medical care to transgender minors. Subjects providers to possibility of healthcare license revocation and civil liability. Prohibits the use of public funds for gender-affirming care to transgender minors.OklahomaSB583 (2021)/HB3240 (2022): Subjects medical professionals who provide some gender-affirming medical or surgical care to transgender adolescents to have their healthcare license revoked.SB676 (2021): Criminalizes the provision of some gender-affirming medical or surgical care to transgender adolescents. Establishes criminal penalties for parents who obtain some gender-affirming medical or surgical care for their children.HB3240 (2022): Creates civil liability for providers and parents in violation. Prohibits the use of public funds for gender-affirming care to minors.South CarolinaHB4047 (2021): Criminalizes the provision of some gender-affirming medical or surgical care to transgender adolescents. Requires school personnel to reveal the gender identity of transgender youth to their parents.South DakotaHB1057 (2020): Criminalizes the provision of gender-affirming medical or surgical care to transgender adolescents.TennesseeSB657 (2021): Criminalizes the provision of gender-affirming medical or surgical care to a transgender adolescent unless both parents or guardians of the adolescent provide a signed written statement from two physicians and an additional board-certified child and adolescent psychiatrist recommending such interventions.HB2835/SB2696 (2022): Subjects medical professionals who provide some gender-affirming medical or surgical care to transgender adolescents to have their healthcare license revoked. Creates civil penalty for medical professionals. Prohibits use of public funds by any entity or person providing gender-affirming care to a minor.TexasHB68 (2021): Adds some gender-affirming medical and surgical care to the state’s definition of child abuse.HB1339 (2021): Prohibits the provision of some gender-affirming medical or surgical care to transgender adolescents Prohibits malpractice insurance providers from providing coverage for damages related to gender-affirming medical or surgical care for transgender adolescents.Governor’s Executive Directive (2022): Orders investigations into parents and medical facilities providing healthcare to transgender adolescents. Based on non-binding interpretation from attorney general that classified gender-affirming care as child abuse.UtahHB127 (2022): Subjects medical professionals who provide some gender-affirming medical or surgical care to transgender adolescents to have their healthcare license revoked.West VirginiaHB2171 (2021): Criminalizes the provision of some gender-affirming medical or surgical care to transgender adolescents.WisconsinSB915 (2022): Prohibits the provision of gender-affirming surgical and medical care to transgender minors. Creates civil liability for providers in violation. Prohibits the use of public funds for gender-affirming care to minors.Table adapted from and expanded from the one published in ref.1Turban J.L. Kraschel K.L. Cohen I.G. Legislation to criminalize gender-affirming medical care for transgender youth.JAMA. 2021; 325: 2251https://doi.org/10.1001/jama.2021.7764Crossref PubMed Scopus (36) Google Scholar Table up to date as of July 1, 2022. Open table in a new tab Table adapted from and expanded from the one published in ref.1Turban J.L. Kraschel K.L. Cohen I.G. Legislation to criminalize gender-affirming medical care for transgender youth.JAMA. 2021; 325: 2251https://doi.org/10.1001/jama.2021.7764Crossref PubMed Scopus (36) Google Scholar Table up to date as of July 1, 2022. The mechanisms by which these laws and proposed legislation seek to limit access to care vary. Some states would criminalize the acts of medical professionals or parents for providing care. For example, Alabama’s law, passed in April of this year, makes providing pubertal suppression or gender-affirming hormones to minors a Class C felony, punishable with up to ten years in prison. Some states would require a medical licensing board to discipline and possibly revoke the license of professionals who provide gender-affirming care to minors. Some states have also considered other modes of restriction, including imposing reporting requirements on educators or limiting public funding. Thankfully, most of these bills have not passed, and some are no longer under consideration. However, given the growing number of states in which this type of legislation was introduced this year and the number of states that reintroduced legislation in 2022 that failed to pass in 2021, state legislators show no signs of relenting. In addition, if the legislative process fails, some states may take action through their executive branch. The Texas legislature did not pass proposed legislation that would have stripped Texas healthcare providers of their medical license for providing gender-affirming care to minors and made such care child abuse. In response, Governor Greg Abbott issued an Executive Directive, affirming a non-binding opinion of the state attorney general that gender-affirming care constitutes child abuse and ordering its Department of Family and Protective Services to investigate parents who provide their children such care. As discussed below, enforcement of the Alabama and Arkansas laws is currently blocked by federal courts while legal challenges proceed, and Governor Abbott’s order is enjoined by Texas state courts. There is nothing inherently unhealthy or abnormal about being trans. However, some trans individuals suffer from a condition termed gender dysphoria, the criteria for which are set out in the American Psychiatric Association’s Diagnostic and Statistical Manual for Mental Disorders (DSM) and include “a marked incongruence between one’s experienced/expressed gender and assigned gender, of at least six months’ duration, that is associated with clinically significant distress or impairment in social, occupational, or other important areas of functioning.”3American Psychiatric AssociationDiagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders.5th edition. American Psychiatric Publishing, 2013Crossref Google Scholar A series of evidence-based clinical guidelines set out the treatment for gender dysphoria, in particular the Endocrine Society Clinical Practice Guideline for Endocrine Treatment of gender-dysphoric/gender-incongruent persons and the World Professional Association for Transgender Health Standards of Care for the Health of Transsexual, Transgender, and Gender-Nonconforming People.4Hembree W.C. Cohen-Kettenis P.T. Gooren L. Hannema S.E. Meyer W.J. Murad M.H. Rosenthal S.M. Safer J.D. Tangpricha V. T’Sjoen G.G. Endocrine treatment of gender-dysphoric/gender-incongruent persons: an endocrine society clinical practice guideline.J. Clin. Endocrinol. Metabol. 2017; 102: 3869-3903https://doi.org/10.1210/jc.2017-01658Crossref PubMed Scopus (1150) Google Scholar,5The World Professional Association for Transgender Health (WPATH), Standards of Care for the Health of Transsexual, Transgender, and Gender Nonconforming People.2012: 24https://www.wpath.org/publications/socVersion: Version 7Google Scholar These guidelines set out the criteria for who is competent to provide gender-affirming care as well as the comprehensive processes that should be followed prior to initiating care. They emphasize that medical interventions are not considered for prepubertal children and that interventions for adolescents are considered in a stepwise fashion from most reversible (i.e., pubertal suppression) to less reversible (i.e., gender-affirming hormones including estrogen or testosterone). While some of these interventions are reversible (i.e., the temporary pausing of endogenous puberty from gonadotropin-releasing hormone agonists [GnRHas]), endogenous puberty itself is irreversible and can cause substantial lifelong psychological distress for those with gender dysphoria, while also often creating the need for more-invasive surgeries later in life. In addition to their use for gender dysphoria, GnRHas have been used in the treatment of central precocious puberty dating back to the 1970s,4Hembree W.C. Cohen-Kettenis P.T. Gooren L. Hannema S.E. Meyer W.J. Murad M.H. Rosenthal S.M. Safer J.D. Tangpricha V. T’Sjoen G.G. Endocrine treatment of gender-dysphoric/gender-incongruent persons: an endocrine society clinical practice guideline.J. Clin. Endocrinol. Metabol. 2017; 102: 3869-3903https://doi.org/10.1210/jc.2017-01658Crossref PubMed Scopus (1150) Google Scholar providing longitudinal safety data for their use in the pediatric population. Research from the precocious puberty literature has shown that, despite assertions by some legislators, these medications do not appear to cause infertility.6Neely E. Lee P. Bloch C. Larsen L. Yang D. Mattia-Goldberg C. Chwalisz K. Leuprolide acetate 1-month depot for central precocious puberty: hormonal suppression and recovery.Int. J. Pediatr. Endocrinol. 2011; 2010: 1https://doi.org/10.1186/1687-9856-2010-398639Crossref Google Scholar However, there is some concern that going directly from pubertal suppression to gender-affirming hormones like estrogen or testosterone may impair fertility. For that reason, existing guidelines recommend fertility counseling prior to adolescent patients pursuing such care, so that they may consider fertility-preservation options.4Hembree W.C. Cohen-Kettenis P.T. Gooren L. Hannema S.E. Meyer W.J. Murad M.H. Rosenthal S.M. Safer J.D. Tangpricha V. T’Sjoen G.G. Endocrine treatment of gender-dysphoric/gender-incongruent persons: an endocrine society clinical practice guideline.J. Clin. Endocrinol. Metabol. 2017; 102: 3869-3903https://doi.org/10.1210/jc.2017-01658Crossref PubMed Scopus (1150) Google Scholar Under existing guidelines, gender-affirming genital surgery is not considered for minors, but gender-affirming chest surgery may be considered for trans masculine adolescents on a case-by-case basis, weighing the substantial risks of surgery against the potential mental and physical health benefits for each individual patient.7Olson-Kennedy J. Warus J. Okonta V. Belzer M. Clark L.F. Chest reconstruction and chest dysphoria in transmasculine minors and young adults: comparisons of nonsurgical and postsurgical cohorts.JAMA Pediatr. 2018; 172: 431-436https://doi.org/10.1001/jamapediatrics.2017.5440Crossref PubMed Scopus (82) Google Scholar,8Mehringer J.E. Harrison J.B. Quain K.M. Shea J.A. Hawkins L.A. Dowshen N.L. Experience of chest dysphoria and masculinizing chest surgery in transmasculine youth.Pediatrics. 2021; 147 (e2020013300)https://doi.org/10.1542/peds.2020-013300Crossref Google Scholar Current guidelines highlight the importance of both informed consent from a minor’s parents and informed assent from the minors themselves prior to the initiation of any gender-affirming medical or surgical care. Alabama’s law provides an example of the flawed reasoning behind these laws. It erroneously claims, among other things, that standard treatment for a transgender adolescent would include genital surgery, when, in fact, the current consensus in the field is to wait until the patient reaches the age of majority before pursuing such surgical procedures. A substantial body of literature exists documenting the benefits of gender-affirming medical interventions, where indicated, for adolescents with gender dysphoria. Over a dozen studies have collectively linked such care to improvements in depression, anxiety, and suicidality.9Turban J.L. King D. Kobe J. Reisner S.L. Keuroghlian A.S. Access to gender-affirming hormones during adolescence and mental health outcomes among transgender adults.PLoS One. 2022; 17e0261039https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0261039Crossref PubMed Scopus (40) Google Scholar,10van der Miesen A.I. Steensma T.D. de Vries A.L. Bos H. Popma A. Psychological functioning in transgender adolescents before and after gender-affirmative care compared with cisgender general population peers.J. Adolesc. Health. 2020; 66: 699-704https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jadohealth.2019.12.018Abstract Full Text Full Text PDF PubMed Scopus (62) Google Scholar Nonetheless, legislators have ignored or omitted any mention of the benefits of gender-affirming care in their legislative findings and have overstated the number of adolescents whose gender dysphoria dissipates without gender-affirming care. It is problematic for the state to interpose itself and prevent the provision of care that is evidence-based, meets clinical guidelines, and takes place in circumstances where parents, adolescents, and healthcare providers are all aligned and supportive of what they as the medical treatment for a given Legislators appear to have out trans adolescent care while parents, and adolescents to the of action for other potential For example, states have not to the of pediatric to back or is that a state like Arkansas that gender-affirming care surgical for minors with such have Scholar Arkansas these with that are young to prohibits gender-affirming care when competent adolescents with their parents and healthcare providers that such standard of care treatment is in the of these laws the use of GnRHas for gender dysphoria while use of these medications for central precocious this is against the of the practice of care for trans some to the but the with the consent going A that requires an to be of would out of current medical that is what legislators are to gender-affirming care. providers are for their They are by practice guidelines, and use their and medical in with their patient in the of a the parents as to provide care that is in their These would their into a criminal In states, criminal with the that is a a its The of medical care, with its should be in all but the of from the care these providers seek to adolescents and their parents is evidence-based and by guidelines of the As has been in areas like medical in what is the standard of care, courts and legislators should to the medical as by the medical to the medical for gender-affirming care is being out in a one would not for other areas of In addition to their flawed and problematic into the practice of laws transgender access to gender-affirming care also legal They may the US state the Care or the with Transgender minors, their parents, and their healthcare providers have brought legal challenges against to gender-affirming care for transgender V. Scholar in Alabama and Arkansas that these laws significant legal of the they on the of transgender minors, their parents, and their providers as by the US and these laws the of transgender minors under the they that against transgender people without an In the Alabama a federal Alabama’s that its criminal was children against that Alabama no evidence to show that medications are and that least major medical in the these medications as evidence-based for gender dysphoria in Scholar in the Arkansas a federal that of children was its law the of for cisgender minors that for transgender Scholar The Alabama also that providers have used medications for to medical other gender dysphoria, such as central precocious hormone for patients whose hormone are Scholar these laws with the of parents to the care, and of their children under the have that this to seek medical care for their children in with their adolescent consent and their make a that medical care is Scholar which medications to medically Scholar these laws the of physicians who provide gender-affirming care to transgender patients by them physicians who provide other of medically Scholar In the Arkansas the concern that law with the the evidence-based practice of and physicians who and medically necessary care to civil liability and of providers in the standard of care for adolescent gender the has that its healthcare providers do not have the to by their which may include medically necessary care for the physical and mental health of their transgender Scholar as is the in if to pass and a state’s executive by or to restrict or criminalize care, such executive action may be to legal challenges under In a state issued a temporary order the Department of Family and Protective Services from Governor Abbott’s to investigate parents of transgender youth gender-affirming care. The issued the that the a cause of action that Governor Abbott V. Scholar challenges may also be including claims under state and federal enforcement of the Care provision or the with In courts are to to that and the or to medications are in a on a case-by-case Scholar not in the and not the of a significant in a that the of medications to transgender minors and was based on the that minors are to have the to consent to such of Scholar The of that a legislative or should on a case-by-case minors are to consent to any of Scholar It is less courts be to on gender-affirming surgeries for transgender the Alabama the to a provision of the Alabama law that surgeries on without legal Scholar the 25 bills to with the gender-affirming care for trans youth as one to use the and of and gender for as We have that these bills the evidence-based clinical guidelines that set out the treatment for gender dysphoria and the evidence documenting the benefits of gender-affirming medical interventions, where indicated, for adolescents with gender dysphoria. We also highlight how is problematic for the state to interpose itself into the individual medical of adolescents, their parents, and healthcare providers by the provision of evidence-based care that meets clinical These laws may some of the most the trans those without the or to or out of state for care. As we some of these laws have already legal challenges on a of for trans youth to have the to gender-affirming care have in some of the challenges It is not how these challenges given a that has to states and of to make medical as we have with

References

7