Characterization of the umbra–penumbra boundary by the vertical component of the magnetic field

P. Lindner, R. Schlichenmaier, N. Bello González

Astronomy and Astrophysics · 2020 · 10 citations · 25 references

DOIFull text

Open access

Concepts

Abstract

Context. The vertical component of the magnetic field was found to reach a constant value at the boundary between penumbra and umbra of stable sunspots in a recent statistical study of Hinode/SP data. This finding has profound implications as it can serve as a criterion to distinguish between fundamentally different magneto-convective modes operating in the sun. Aims. The objective of this work is to verify the existence of a constant value for the vertical component of the magnetic field ( B ⊥ ) at the boundary between umbra and penumbra from ground-based data in the near-infrared wavelengths and to determine its value for the GREGOR Infrared Spectrograph (GRIS@GREGOR) data. This is the first statistical study on the Jurčák criterion with ground-based data, and we compare it with the results from space-based data (Hinode/SP and SDO/HMI). Methods. Eleven spectropolarimetric data sets from the GRIS@GREGOR slit-spectograph containing fully-fledged stable sunspots were selected from the GRIS archive. SIR inversions including a polarimetric straylight correction are used to produce maps of the magnetic field vector using the Fe I 15648 Å and 15662 Å lines. Averages of B ⊥ along the contours between penumbra and umbra are analyzed for the 11 data sets. In addition, contours at the resulting B ⊥ const are drawn onto maps and compared to intensity contours. The geometric difference between these contours, Δ P , is calculated for each data set. Results. Averaged over the 11 sunspots, we find a value of B ⊥ const = (1787 ± 100) gauss. The difference from the values previously derived from Hinode/SP and SDO/HMI data is explained by instrumental differences and by the formation characteristics of the respective lines that were used. Contours at B ⊥ = B ⊥ const and contours calculated in intensity maps match from a visual inspection and the geometric distance Δ P was found to be on the order of 2 pixels. Furthermore, the standard deviation between different data sets of averages along umbra–penumbra contours is smaller for B ⊥ than for B ∥ by a factor of 2.4. Conclusions. Our results provide further support to the Jurčák criterion with the existence of an invariable value B ⊥ const at the umbra–penumbra boundary. This fundamental property of sunspots can act as a constraining parameter in the calibration of analysis techniques that calculate magnetic fields. It also serves as a requirement for numerical simulations to be realistic. Furthermore, it is found that the geometric difference, Δ P , between intensity contours and contours at B ⊥ = B ⊥ const acts as an index of stability for sunspots.

References

25