People focus on optimistic scenarios and disregard pessimistic scenarios while predicting task completion times.

Ian R. Newby‐Clark, Michael G. Ross, Roger Buehler, Derek J. Koehler, Dale Griffin

Journal of Experimental Psychology Applied · 2000 · 145 citations · 14 references

DOIFull text

Open access

Concepts

Abstract

Task completion plans normally resemble best-case scenarios and yield overly optimistic predictions of completion times. The authors induced participants to generate more pessimistic scenarios and examined completion predictions. Participants described a pessimistic scenario of task completion either alone or with an optimistic scenario. Pessimistic scenarios did not affect predictions or accuracy and were consistently rated less plausible than optimistic scenarios (Experiments 1-3). Experiment 4 independently manipulated scenario plausibility and optimism. Plausibility moderated the impact of optimistic, but not pessimistic, scenarios. Experiment 5 supported a motivational explanation of the tendency to disregard pessimistic scenarios regardless of their plausibility. People took pessimistic scenarios into account when predicting someone else's completion times. The authors conclude that pessimistic-scenario generation may not be an effective debiasing technique for personal predictions.

References

14