International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health · 2021 · 21 citations · 65 references
Public AffairsPsychologyEvidence-based PracticeExperimental DesignOutcomes ResearchEvidence-based InterventionsExperimental EvaluationMixed-methods EvaluationOutcome EvaluationTheory-based EvaluationTranslating Evidence Into PracticeBehavioral Intervention TrialsCausal Inference In EvaluationData EvaluationEvidence-based Intervention AdaptationHuman Intervention TrialsIntervention-based PracticeMixed Methods Data Collection
Realist evaluation offers a valuable way to understand how interventions function and thus how they can be improved and locally adapted. Consequently, realist evaluation is increasingly conducted in parallel with intervention trials. It comprises a clear philosophical foundation and view of causality, pragmatic mixed data collection methods, and a theory-driven approach in which hypothesised program theories are tested and refined. However, detailed methods for data analysis are seldom well-described in realist studies and no clear method for analysing and presenting realist evaluation data has yet emerged. In this methodological paper we use the worked example of our realist process evaluation of the SAGE yoga trial to illustrate an applied process of data analysis and presentation of findings. We show how we drew on other realist studies for ideas, provide examples of six key tasks involved in conducting a realist process evaluation (including coding data and structuring results) and describe strategies that did not work and our rationale for rejecting them. This detailed account of the decisions and methods that worked for us is intended to provide a practical and informed point of departure for researchers conducting a realist evaluation.
65
Qualitative Data Analysis: An Expanded Sourcebook
Journal of Environmental Psychology · 1994 · 45.6K citations
Process evaluation of complex interventions: Medical Research Council guidance
Gary F. Moore, Suzanne Audrey, Mary Barker et al. · BMJ · 2015 · 6.5K citations · Full text
Public Affairs, Health Policy, Comparative Effectiveness Research +9
RAMESES II reporting standards for realist evaluations
Geoff Wong, Gill Westhorp, Ana Manzano et al. · BMC Medicine · 2016 · 918 citations · Full text