The streaming network: Conceptualizing distribution economy, technology, and power in streaming media services

Terje Colbjørnsen

Convergence The International Journal of Research into New Media Technologies · 2020 · 84 citations · 27 references

DOIFull text

Open access

Concepts

TL;DR

Streaming services have existed for over a decade yet remain under‑conceptualized, and this study draws on network, platform, and algorithmic power theories to frame the phenomenon. The paper argues that streaming constitutes a distinct digital media distribution network and seeks to identify its constituent nodes and the power relations among them. Using Spotify, Apple Music, Netflix, and Kindle Unlimited as case studies, the authors conduct a stepwise analysis and visualization of how human and nonhuman actors are linked through content, data, and money flows, as well as control, access, and exposure relationships. The analysis reveals asymmetrical power dynamics: users and content providers are vulnerable, no single actor can dominate, while streaming providers and device/software makers can maneuver the network to strengthen their relative position.

Abstract

Despite there being more than a decade since the introductions of Netflix’ and Spotify’s online services, few attempts have been made to thoroughly examine and conceptualize streaming and streaming services across culture and media industries. The argument proposed here is that streaming constitutes a distinct form of digital media distribution network, what I refer to as the streaming network. The article asks what constitutes the parts or nodes of such a streaming network, and further what the power relationships between the various parts are. The analysis uses Spotify, Apple Music, Netflix, and Kindle Unlimited as examples, building on a wide array of primary and secondary document sources. The analysis contains a stepwise discussion and visualization of how human and nonhuman actors in this streaming network are connected by way of flows of content, data, and money, as well as by relationships of control, access, and exposure. The argument draws on theories of network power, platform power, and algorithmic power. The analysis highlights the asymmetrical relationships between, on the one hand, users and content providers, and on the other, streaming providers and device and software makers. No single actor in the network is able to exercise full control, but users and content originators are seen as particularly vulnerable. Streaming providers and device and software makers are able to maneuver the network to strengthen their relative position.

References

27