Journal of Attention Disorders · 2020 · 37 citations · 41 references
MedicinePsychiatryPsychologyBehavioral DisordersNeuropsychiatryPsychometricsAttention-deficit/hyperactivity DisorderCognitive AssessmentNeurocognitive AssessmentNeuropsychological AssessmentTest ReliabilityWorking MemoryAdhd DiagnosisAdhd SymptomatologyAdult Attention Deficit Hyperactivity DisorderAttention Deficit AssessmentCriterion ValidityMemory TestNeuropsychological Assessment Of AttentionSymptom Reporting Instruments
Objective: This study examined concordance between symptom and performance validity among clinically-referred patients undergoing neuropsychological evaluation for Attention-Deficit/Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD). Method: Data from 203 patients who completed the WAIS-IV Working Memory Index, the Clinical Assessment of Attention Deficit-Adult (CAT-A), and ≥4 criterion performance validity tests (PVTs) were analyzed. Results: Symptom and performance validity were concordant in 76% of cases, with the majority being valid performance. Of the remaining 24% of cases with divergent validity findings, patients were more likely to exhibit symptom invalidity (15%) than performance invalidity (9%). Patients demonstrating symptom invalidity endorsed significantly more ADHD symptoms than those with credible symptom reporting ( ηp 2 = .06–.15), but comparable working memory test performance, whereas patients with performance invalidity had significantly worse working memory performance than those with valid PVT performance ( ηp 2 = .18). Conclusion: Symptom and performance invalidity represent dissociable constructs in patients undergoing neuropsychological evaluation of ADHD and should be evaluated independently.
41
Laura A. Rabin, Emily W. Paolillo, William Barr · Archives of Clinical Neuropsychology · 2016 · 430 citations · Full text