Evaluation and improvement of isothermal amplification methods for point-of-need plant disease diagnostics

Yiping Zou, Michael G. Mason, José Ramón Botella

PLoS ONE · 2020 · 130 citations · 55 references

DOIFull text

Open access

Concepts

TL;DR

Isothermal DNA amplification technologies are considered ideal for point‑of‑need diagnostics because they operate at a single temperature, enabling use of simple heat sources such as a water bath. The study aimed to identify the most suitable isothermal method for low‑resource point‑of‑need applications by evaluating several candidates. The evaluation assessed simplicity, cost, sensitivity, and reproducibility of each method. LAMP and RPA emerged as the most suitable single‑step, highly sensitive, reproducible technologies; LAMP speed increased up to 76 % with loop primers and other optimizations, whereas RPA performance could not be improved, yet both remain viable for on‑site diagnostics with minimal equipment.

Abstract

A number of isothermal DNA amplification technologies claim to be ideal for point-of-need (PON) applications as they enable reactions to be performed using a single-temperature heat source (e.g. water bath). Thus, we examined several isothermal amplification methods focusing on simplicity, cost, sensitivity and reproducibility to identify the most suitable method(s) for low resource PON applications. A number of methods were found unsuitable as they either involved multiple temperature incubations, were relatively expensive or required relatively large amounts target DNA for amplification. Among the methods examined, loop-mediated isothermal amplification (LAMP) and recombinase polymerase amplification (RPA) were found to be the most suitable for PON applications as they are both single step methods that provide highly sensitive and reproducible amplifications. The speed of LAMP reactions was greatly enhanced, up to 76%, with the addition of loop primers while the presence of swarm primers and the sequestration of free magnesium ions with nucleotides also enhanced the amplification speed. In contrast, we were unable to enhance RPA's performance from the original published literature. While both RPA and LAMP have some drawbacks, either isothermal technology can reliably be used for on-site diagnostics with minimal equipment.

References

55