Health Information Systems in the Digital Health Ecosystem—Problems and Solutions for Ethics, Trust and Privacy

Pekka Ruotsalainen, Bernd Blobel

International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health · 2020 · 60 citations · 49 references

DOIFull text

Open access

Concepts

TL;DR

Digital health information systems increasingly collect, use, and share vast amounts of personal health information without user control or authorization, creating new ethical, privacy, and trust challenges. The authors aim to identify a combination of ethical principles, privacy, and trust models that enable the design and implementation of DHIS that are ethical, trustworthy, and privacy‑supporting. They analyze existing literature through systems theory, systems engineering, and heuristic methods, proposing an ethical model that blends consequentialism, professional medical ethics, and utilitarianism, defining privacy as a contextual intellectual property right with user‑expressed policies, and applying computational trust via linguistic values and fuzzy mathematics. Their integrated solution demonstrates a new approach to creating ethically acceptable, trustworthy, and privacy‑enabling DHIS and digital health ecosystems.

Abstract

Digital health information systems (DHIS) are increasingly members of ecosystems, collecting, using and sharing a huge amount of personal health information (PHI), frequently without control and authorization through the data subject. From the data subject’s perspective, there is frequently no guarantee and therefore no trust that PHI is processed ethically in Digital Health Ecosystems. This results in new ethical, privacy and trust challenges to be solved. The authors’ objective is to find a combination of ethical principles, privacy and trust models, together enabling design, implementation of DHIS acting ethically, being trustworthy, and supporting the user’s privacy needs. Research published in journals, conference proceedings, and standards documents is analyzed from the viewpoint of ethics, privacy and trust. In that context, systems theory and systems engineering approaches together with heuristic analysis are deployed. The ethical model proposed is a combination of consequentialism, professional medical ethics and utilitarianism. Privacy enforcement can be facilitated by defining it as health information specific contextual intellectual property right, where a service user can express their own privacy needs using computer-understandable policies. Thereby, privacy as a dynamic, indeterminate concept, and computational trust, deploys linguistic values and fuzzy mathematics. The proposed solution, combining ethical principles, privacy as intellectual property and computational trust models, shows a new way to achieve ethically acceptable, trustworthy and privacy-enabling DHIS and Digital Health Ecosystems.

References

49