Comments on “Trial Summary on the Comparison of Various Non‐Aflatoxigenic Strains of <i>Aspergillus flavus</i> on Mycotoxin Levels and Yield in Maize” by M.S. Molo, et al. Agron. J. 111:942–946 (2019)

Alejandro Ortega‐Beltran, Ranajit Bandyopadhyay, Megan S. Molo, Ignazio Carbone, Ronnie W. Heiniger, Leah Boerema

Agronomy Journal · 2019 · 12 citations · 56 references

DOIFull text

Open access

Concepts

Abstract

Dear Editor We read with great interest the recently published study in Agronomy Journal in which use of native Aspergillus flavus strains as biocontrol agents was described as an effective strategy to limit aflatoxin contamination of maize (Molo et al., 34). The Molo et al. (34) study was conducted during a single season, in a single field of a research station in the state of North Carolina. Yet, the authors, in our opinion, make nonrigorous comments and conclusions related to this important biocontrol technology. We also have read online news articles—one in the web portal of the American Society of Agronomy—related to Molo et al. (34) in which it is implied that the use of native atoxigenic strains to limit crop aflatoxin content is a novel concept (Chakravorty, 13; Fisk, 25). Merriam-Webster Dictionary defines novel as, “new and not resembling something formerly known or used”. The concept of native atoxigenic strains to limit crop aflatoxin content was introduced in the late 1980s (Cole and Cotty, 14; Cotty, 15) and even discussed in a 2010 article (Burness Communications, 11) by one web portal also providing commentary on Molo et al. (34) (American Society of Agronomy, 3). Molo et al. (34) and the online news commentaries on the article provide readers inaccurate interpretations of the status of aflatoxin biocontrol technology across the globe. The article leaves the impression that use of native atoxigenic strains is new, whereas this concept is one of the bases of aflatoxin management through biocontrol with atoxigenic A. flavus active ingredients (Mehl et al., 33) and use of native atoxigenic strains is mentioned in the title of a patent issued in 1992 by the US government (Cotty, 16). The first reports of native atoxigenic strain efficacy in cotton (Cotty, 17, 18) and maize (Brown et al., 10) were made almost three decades ago, and benefits of using native atoxigenic strains mentioned in the news commentaries in terms of soil and climate adaptation are concepts stressed in several publications (Cotty, 20; Probst et al., 42; Mehl et al., 33; Atehnkeng et al., 5, 4; Bandyopadhyay et al., 8). Results of Molo et al. (34) should be considered as a preliminary indication that native atoxigenic strains are also beneficial for limiting maize aflatoxin content in North Carolina. Native atoxigenic Aspergillus flavus have been used for decades to limit crop aflatoxin content. When applied correctly, commercial atoxigenic biocontrol products reduce aflatoxin content. Farmers continue using commercial products because treatments result in low aflatoxin levels. Influence of mating between atoxigenic strains in reducing aflatoxin content is questionable. Atoxigenic strains should be tested in multiple farmers’ fields, in multiple environments, over multiple years. The first atoxigenic biocontrol product, Aspergillus flavus AF36, has been used for decades in areas where members of the vegetative compatibility group (VCG) YV36, to which the active ingredient fungus belong, are native (Cotty et al., 21; Doster et al., 24; Grubisha and Cotty, 27). Aspergillus flavus AF36 was initially registered with USEPA for experimental commercial field treatment (up to 20,000 acres per year) in 1996 and received unrestricted registration from USEPA in 2003 (USEPA, 45). Supporting data for registration of AF36 for use on cotton and subsequent amendments for use on maize, pistachio, almond, and fig (USEPA, 46, 47) included demonstration that the VCG is native to target areas and is effective in hundreds of farmer field trials of the various crops. The environmental safety of the product and its benefits to the farmers were additional criteria for registration (Cotty, 20; Cotty et al., 21; Doster et al., 24; Ortega-Beltran et al., 39). Aspergillus flavus AF36 is a commercially available product used annually by farmers to treat several hundred thousand acres in aflatoxin-prone areas of the United States, primarily in Arizona, Texas, and California. The active ingredient fungus is a strain native to the environments in which it is used. The range of YV36, apart from vast areas of the United States, extends over all areas of Mexico where frequencies of YV36 have been investigated (Ortega-Beltran et al., 36). Indeed, because YV36 is native to Mexico, trials of AF36 in maize in Mexico are scheduled to take place during 2019 (N. Palacios, personal communication, 2019). The second atoxigenic strain-based biocontrol product, Afla-Guard, has an active ingredient that is distinct from AF36 but also native and widely distributed. Afla-Guard is commercially applied on maize and peanuts in the United States. The online news commentaries reporting the so-called novel technology mention that, “commercial strains may not be the only answer’ and that, “use of safe, native strains can be as effective, or more effective, than commercial strains” (Chakravorty, 13; Fisk, 25) despite one of Molo et al.’s core ideas: “Native and commercially available biocontrol strains are equally effective in reducing AF levels.” Combinations of atoxigenic strains have not been used intensively in the United States, where use of single native-strain aflatoxin biocontrol products predominate (Cotty et al., 22; Dorner, 23; Mehl et al., 33). However, an aflatoxin biocontrol product with four native strains for use in maize in Texas, FourSure (Shenge et al., 44), has received a USEPA Experimental Use Permit (USEPA, 48). The US Texas Corn Producers Board is seeking the registration of FourSure. Use of mixtures of native atoxigenic strains to treat almond, pistachio, and fig crops in California is also being pursued (Picot et al., 40; Ortega-Beltran et al., 38). At some point, some or all of the strains reported by Molo et al. (34) may be formulated into a product for use in commercially-produced crops. Reaching the commercial stage does not demote atoxigenic strains from native status if used in areas where they are common. Although no statistical data was provided, it seems that maize treated with AF36 and Afla-Guard had similar aflatoxin levels to maize treated with both IC6510+IC6511. In addition, Molo et al. (34) does not contain information on how the strains were formulated and applied, the carrier (e.g., wheat, sorghum, barley), whether the commercial products Afla-Guard and AF36 were used, the dose, how physically separated were the treatments, whether strains applied in one treatment were found in maize from other treatments, or if the various tested strains differed in inducing kernel rot. The commercial products AF36 (current product is AF36 Prevail) and Afla-Guard have different formulations. It is important to point out that the strains were applied at tasseling. For maize, AF36 is recommended to be broadcasted 2 to 3 wk before tasseling. Moreover, the two commercial products were not tested in combination with one of the other tested strains. Further, data for effectiveness of IC6512, one of the two strains in the combination with the lowest aflatoxin content (although all treatments appear statistically the same), was not tested individually or the data is not provided. In the news commentaries it is mentioned that, “using commercial strains can have some disadvantages. They usually need to be reapplied each year, at a cost of $20 per acre. Also, the application has to be done aerially or manually”. It would be valuable to know how the strains were applied in the North Carolina study. Commercial biocontrol application is done once per cropping season. Frequently, as recommended by agronomists, susceptible crops are not planted on the same land in multiple years in succession but are rotated. Depending on the crop and the context, the biocontrol products (i.e., sterile grains coated with the active ingredient fungi) are applied aerially or by tractor as in most cottonseed and maize fields in the United States (http://www.azcotton.org/aflotoxin36/af36images/GroundApplicationPhotos/groundapp.html, accessed 5 Apr. 2019), by quad motorcycle in pistachio and almond orchards in the United States (http://www.azcotton.org/aflatoxin36/af36images/PistachioApplication/pistachioapp.html, http://kare.ucanr.edu/programs/Plant_Pathology/Biocontrol_of_Aflatoxins_in_Pistachio_and_Almond_Crops, accessed 5 Apr. 2019), or manually by smallholder maize and groundnut farmers in African nations (Bandyopadhyay et al., 8). News commentaries (e.g., American Society of Agronomy, 3) also indicate that the cost of an application, “can deter farmers from using commercial strains”. Farmers treat crops with pesticides to protect against insects and plant pathogens. Agronomic packages including fertilizers and herbicides are far more expensive than the cost of treating crops with atoxigenic strains and the costs do not prevent input use. In the United States, there is a significant cost for growing a crop that exceeds maximum allowable aflatoxin levels. In aflatoxin-prone areas, treating crops with atoxigenic products provides opportunity to enter premium markets that in most cases would not be possible without biocontrol use. It is also necessary to explain reasons to expect commercial atoxigenic strains will not remain in treated fields indefinitely, or for a long-term. Fungal community compositions are highly dynamic among and within years, even in single fields, and in both treated and non-treated areas (Bayman and Cotty, 9; Mehl et al., 33; Ortega-Beltran and Cotty, 37). When fields are treated with atoxigenic strains, the composition of the fungal community associated with the crop changes so that the atoxigenic strains are very common. The changed community remains with crop remnants between seasons. However, other fungi resident in the soil also compete for resources associated with the next crop as do fungi arriving to the field from near and distant areas. Typically applied atoxigenic strains compose over 50% of the A. flavus community in the soil a year after application (Cotty, 19, 20) providing potential for additive effects with multiple year treatments and the potential to beneficially change the fungal community across large areas (Bandyopadhyay et al., 8). Molo et al. (34) also indicates that combinations of biocontrol strains of opposite mating type may be more effective in limiting aflatoxin concentrations of treated crops compared to using single atoxigenic genotypes, which contain one of the two possible mating types in A. flavus. Occurrence of sexual recombination of A. flavus in sufficient frequency to be of epidemiological significance under natural conditions has been questioned in several well planned, multi-year studies examining fungal populations from cultivated and non-cultivated areas in the Americas and Africa (Grubisha and Cotty, 26, 27; Adhikari et al., 1; Ortega-Beltran et al., 36; Islam et al., 30). On the other hand, if mating occurs under field conditions as a result of biocontrol applications as proposed by Molo et al. (34), then atoxigenic strains composing commercial products would be mating with those of opposite mating type residing in the treated fields. The effect that Molo et al. (34) claim to happen will also occur in those fields treated with a commercial product. However, in the Molo et al. (34) paper it is stated, “The full impact of formulations comprising a mix of sexually compatible MAT1–1/MAT1–2 mating types is expected long term because the mating process takes 6–11 mo in the laboratory (Horn et al., 2009a); however, a signature of genetic exchange and recombination has been detected just 3 mo after biocontrol application (M.S. Molo et al., unpublished data).” It is not clear how a long-term and fastidious process of sexual reproduction would impact the efficacy of strain combinations applied in the field in either the short term or the long term (Grubisha and Cotty, 26, 27). Some of the applied fungi will move beyond treated fields and likewise fungi from neighboring areas will migrate to treated fields during the course of the year. Conditions in any given field are by no means stable as in the laboratory. Also, the signature of genetic exchange and recombination is reported to be long after strain application, 3 mo after harvest. Although not mentioned in the paper, the maize should have been harvested about 45 d after application. Rather than a recombination event influencing aflatoxin content, a more parsimonious explanation for the low aflatoxin content is simple competitive exclusion of aflatoxin producers residing in the field. Use of single-genotype atoxigenic biocontrol products has allowed cultivation of susceptible crops in aflatoxin-prone areas. That is, use of single-genotype atoxigenic biocontrol products allows production of aflatoxin-compliant crops that can be commercialized in the most stringent markets across the globe. In the case of AF36, farmers in Arizona, Texas, and California continue to use AF36, a single-native atoxigenic strain biocontrol product because of the substantial reductions obtained when treating cottonseed, maize, and pistachio with the product. If AF36 was not effective in limiting crop aflatoxin content to compliant and safe levels, the thousands of farmers that use it would have discontinued treating their crops. At this point we have only mentioned native atoxigenic biocontrol usage in the United States and early-stage usage in Mexico. Since 2003, the International Institute of Tropical Agriculture (IITA) in collaboration with the US Department of Agriculture–Agricultural Research Service (USDA–ARS), along with many partners, have developed several atoxigenic biocontrol products under the trade name Aflasafe for use in various African nations (www.aflasafe.com). Each Aflasafe product contains four atoxigenic A. flavus strains belonging to widely-distributed VCGs native to the countries for which the Aflasafe product was developed (Bandyopadhyay et al., 8). Aflasafe strains composing different products contain partial or complete aflatoxin biosynthesis gene cluster deletions (Adhikari et al., 1). Several Aflasafe products also contain active ingredient atoxigenic strains with opposite mating type (unpublished data, R. Bandyopadhyay et al., 7). Biocontrol products with multiple native atoxigenic strain active ingredients have been validated in African environments and approved by regulatory authorities responsible for pesticide registrations in several African nations (Bandyopadhyay et al., 8; Schreurs et al., 43) following field efficacy trials in hundreds of farmers’ fields in multiple agro-ecological zones and during multiple years (Atehnkeng et al., 6, 5; Bandyopadhyay et al., 8). Aflatoxin reductions in crops from treated fields range from 75 to 100% compared to untreated adjoining crops, even in highly challenging conditions that smallholder farmers frequently face across Africa. The reductions are observed both at harvest and even after poor storage (Atehnkeng et al., 5). Aflasafe products are commercially available for use in Nigeria, Kenya, Senegal, The Gambia, Burkina Faso, Ghana, Tanzania, Zambia, Malawi, and Mozambique (Bandyopadhyay et al., 8, 7; Schreurs et al., 43). More Aflasafe products are expected to be registered soon for use in other African nations. Use of Aflasafe products, composed of mixtures of native atoxigenic strains, is also mentioned in a paper reviewing cultural and genetic approaches to limit crop aflatoxin content (Ojiambo et al., 35). Carbone, a of the Molo et al. (34) paper, is also a of that In addition, of biocontrol products using native atoxigenic strains is at different in et al., et al., et al., et al., et al., et al., et al., and other countries from where publications are not available (e.g., and The made by Molo et al. (34) as a result of biocontrol application is and we that it additional research In the same smallholder farmers have that their groundnut crops when treated with Aflasafe a product developed for use in and The accessed Apr. 2019). In from to the thousands of maize farmers that used Aflasafe to treat over of commercially-produced maize had on a 50% compared to the maize in their areas et al., 43). The was to and of and among other Influence of Aflasafe application on should also be investigated in Nigeria, The Gambia, and In the concept of using native atoxigenic strains has been in the for decades and is not The use of biocontrol products with multiple native atoxigenic strain active ingredients has been for well over a both in Africa and the United States. was to no opportunity for a recombination event to occur between atoxigenic strains of opposite mating type during the short between application and and other should have been responsible for the observed low aflatoxin levels. of atoxigenic strains during research studies is not to commercial usage is possible after a registration of technology and that can over 5 an use of and data from the research during registration of commercial products is to the registration process of products (Ortega-Beltran et al., 38). field efficacy of atoxigenic strains should be conducted in multiple farmers’ fields, in multiple and over multiple years. We Cotty, and for their valuable comments on the Dear Editor The use of atoxigenic strains of Aspergillus flavus as biocontrol agents has to be very effective in reducing aflatoxin contamination in the United States (Cotty, Dorner, and (Atehnkeng et al., Bandyopadhyay et al., et al., et al., The commentary provides a very of how native strains of A. flavus have been to reduce aflatoxin contamination of crops. reported by the of the biocontrol using atoxigenic A. flavus strains is very effective not only in the short term of a single growing but there is also some over to multiple years (Cotty, and et al., The Molo et study takes this biocontrol strategy one by our of the of A. flavus and fungal mating in strains for biocontrol The news article this in the against (Chakravorty, Fisk, out in the news article when to Molo et al. the study also that combinations of native strains are more effective than commercial strains in reducing aflatoxin levels. because the combinations take of fungal their mating types are to and their Fungal mating is the novel of the Molo et al. paper, and not strains” per or mixtures of native strains that do not mating this commentary the to made in the news (Chakravorty, Fisk, which more on the native strains than fungal is because Molo et al. that, “Native and commercially available biocontrol strains are equally effective in reducing AF levels.” and that strains of opposite mating types in combination can to the in AF The of this commentary are their of the news article and of the Molo et al. Molo et al. do not make comments on biocontrol and its efficacy and state as a core that, strains are effective at reducing AF levels in The Molo et al. paper reports that a comprising native strains of opposite mating types be in the efficacy of single strain biocontrol formulations. The of the commentary are not one of the of the Molo et al. Native strains of opposite mating type can to of aflatoxin contamination of Molo et al. was published as a and and as the are preliminary but Molo et al. for the first that the mating type composition of a biocontrol product may reduce aflatoxin concentrations and also to fungal mating and A. flavus as described by Molo et al. have not been criteria to in biocontrol formulations. out in this commentary there are biocontrol formulations that multiple A. flavus strains, but mating type and fungal were not a in those strains. Since the of mating types et al., and the sexual state in A. flavus (Horn et al., have been to type strains in biocontrol formulations. For the strains used in Afla-Guard and AF36 biocontrol products are of the same mating type but to different fungal and which be important in the of et al., In some the mating types of strains used as active ingredients in other biocontrol products have been reported et al. or but not but field trials on how different mating type combinations in reducing aflatoxin contamination have not been The biocontrol is that a competitive atoxigenic strain of A. flavus to the crop to harvest to reduce aflatoxin contamination in a field. When the impact of commercial atoxigenic strains and as biocontrol agents on the genetic of A. flavus in field populations over we in the short term 45 d after biocontrol a signature of and mating type that are highly to one mating type which would be with the competitive exclusion (Cotty and Mehl and Cotty, Mehl et al., 3 in to there is also a signature of genetic exchange between the applied biocontrol and native strains, which would reduce aflatoxin levels in strains et al., field populations mating type and aflatoxin levels are The of genetic between the biocontrol strain and native strains that populations can even when the applied biocontrol agents are of a single mating Molo et al. for the first that the aflatoxin levels can be if biocontrol products strains of compatible mating The Molo et al. paper is the first study to that mating type composition and in fields may have a in biocontrol and the stage for to the genetic that can explain the of sexual reproduction in the efficacy of biocontrol and into how to is that sexual reproduction within A. flavus is in and the genetic on reproduction in as as wk and to mo (Horn et al., of vegetative compatibility in the same from year to year (Atehnkeng et al., and Cotty, and in strains when compared to VCGs after a single of et al., is an important because each VCG is a and all within a VCG are of the same mating either or VCGs can only from mating between strains of different there is of recombination within VCGs through in the field et al., over and of A. flavus in laboratory (Horn et al., et al., where the of strains from to be out under field conditions (Horn et al., is by studies that to providing of recombination in field populations of A. flavus et al., et al., et al., and among related et al., et al., are many and in using as genetic in the studies reported in the commentary (Grubisha and Cotty, Islam et al., Ortega-Beltran et al., when it to the and of recombination and Carbone, as out in a A. flavus genetic study using the same of et al., Grubisha and Cotty, this the of examining single from multiple et al., et al., et al., et al., and for and of recombination in populations of A. flavus. all of the it is clear that recombination is the more parsimonious explanation than for the observed genetic in A. flavus. The of this commentary the and of the of sexual reproduction in both and including genetic in A. flavus and how this genetic and a single paper reporting on recombination and sexual reproduction in populations of A. which are because they Afla-Guard and AF36, has been in this and we that the of et al. was in to was in Molo et al. the commentary is with the of biocontrol using atoxigenic native strains it short in the of on the and mating of A. flavus which are the to with the potential to biocontrol

References

56