Punish or Protect? How Close Relationships Shape Responses to Moral Violations

Aaron C. Weidman, Walter J. Sowden, Martha K. Berg, Ethan Kross

Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin · 2019 · 96 citations · 29 references

Concepts

TL;DR

People have fundamental tendencies to punish immoral actors and treat close others altruistically. The study asks whether these tendencies collide, leading people to punish or protect close others who behave immorally. Self‑distancing is identified as a psychological mechanism that reduces the tendency to protect close others who commit severe moral infractions. Across 10 studies (N = 2,847), participants consistently anticipated protecting close others who committed severe infractions such as theft and sexual harassment, a tendency that held across gender, politics, moral foundations, and disgust sensitivity, was driven by self‑interest, loyalty, and harm concerns, and was mitigated by self‑distancing.

Abstract

People have fundamental tendencies to punish immoral actors and treat close others altruistically. What happens when these tendencies collide—do people punish or protect close others who behave immorally? Across 10 studies ( N = 2,847), we show that people consistently anticipate protecting close others who commit moral infractions, particularly highly severe acts of theft and sexual harassment. This tendency emerged regardless of gender, political orientation, moral foundations, and disgust sensitivity and was driven by concerns about self-interest, loyalty, and harm. We further find that people justify this tendency by planning to discipline close others on their own. We also identify a psychological mechanism that mitigates the tendency to protect close others who have committed severe (but not mild) moral infractions: self-distancing. These findings highlight the role that relational closeness plays in shaping people’s responses to moral violations, underscoring the need to consider relational closeness in future moral psychology work.

References

29