Academy of Management Review · 2019 · 143 citations · 127 references
ManagementStrategic ManagementStrategyAgency TheoryEpistemologyStrategic Decision-makingDecision Making Under RiskDecision Under UncertaintyDecision-making Under UncertaintyFree WillRational ChoiceActorsDecision Making Under Incomplete InformationDecision Theory Under UncertaintyEpistemic Free WillEpistemic UncertaintyFirst CauseStrategic Decision-making Under UncertaintyUncertainty In Decision Making
Managers face a critical issue in deciding when to employ a predictive planning approach versus a more adaptive and flexible strategic approach. We suggest that determining which approach is ideal for a given context hangs on the extent to which uncertainty is, or might be, mitigable within that context. To date, however, the mitigability of uncertainty has not been adequately distilled. Here, we take on this issue, distinguishing mitigable ignorance of pertinent but knowable information (i.e., “epistemic uncertainty”) from immitigable indeterminacy (i.e., “aleatory uncertainty”). We review the current state of the debate on the existence of free will, because the acceptance or rejection of conscious agents as a true first cause has fundamental implications. A critical examination of the arguments for and against the free will hypothesis land us on the side of voluntarism, which implies immitigable indeterminacy (but not complete unpredictability) wherever conscious actors are involved. Accepting the existence of immitigable or aleatory uncertainty, then, we revisit the determination of strategic logics and produce important theoretical nuance and key boundary conditions in the normative choice between predictive and nonpredictive strategies.
127
Prospect Theory: An Analysis of Decision under Risk
Daniel Kahneman, Amos Tversky · Econometrica · 1979 · 47K citations
Firm Resources and Sustained Competitive Advantage
Jay B. Barney · Journal of Management · 1991 · 45.6K citations
Dynamic capabilities and strategic management
David J. Teece, Gary P. Pisano, Amy Shuen · Strategic Management Journal · 1997 · 31.5K citations
A resource‐based view of the firm
Birger Wernerfelt · Strategic Management Journal · 1984 · 24.8K citations · Full text