Philosophy of Science · 2019 · 58 citations · 21 references
ManagementOrganization StudiesGroup DynamicsPhilosophy Of ScienceTeamworkCollaborative Decision-makingConsensus BuildingInterdisciplinary CollaborationScientific ConsensusCollaborative Research EthicsConsensusScientific AgreementScientific Consensus FormationScientific DisagreementTeam-based Science
I argue that collaborators do not need to reach broad agreement over the justification of a consensus claim. This is because maintaining a diversity of justifiers within a scientific collaboration has important epistemic value. I develop a view of collective justification that depends on the diversity of epistemic perspectives present in a group. I argue that a group can be collectively justified in asserting that P as long as the disagreement among collaborators over the reasons for P is itself justified. In conclusion, I make a case for multimethod collaborative research and work through an example in the social sciences.
21
Robust research needs many lines of evidence
Marcus R. Munafò, George Davey Smith · Nature · 2018 · 704 citations · Full text
Empirically Based, Agent-based models
Marco A. Janssen · Ecology and Society · 2006 · 593 citations · Full text
The Epistemic Benefit of Transient Diversity
Kevin Zollman · Erkenntnis · 2009 · 465 citations