BMC Medical Education · 2019 · 16 citations · 33 references
MedicineClinical SciencesMedical EducationClinical MedicineOutcomes ResearchResidency TrainingClinical PlacementsHealth Program EvaluationIntegration Of Clinical SciencesStudy DesignSubject EnrollmentSubject RecruitmentClinical Placement AssessmentClinical Placement EvaluationClinical Program EvaluationFormal CurriculumMedical Student EducationProgram Outcomes EvaluationResearch Experiences For UndergraduatesStudent Experience Measurement
BACKGROUND: Summer student research programs (SSRPs) serve to generate student interest in research and a clinician-scientist career path. This study sought to understand the composition of existing medically-related Canadian SSRPs, describe the current selection, education and evaluation practices and highlight opportunities for improvement. METHODS: A cross-sectional survey study among English-language-based medically-related Canadian SSRPs for undergraduate and medical students was conducted. Programs were systematically identified through academic and/or institutional websites. The survey, administered between June-August 2016, collected information on program demographics, competition, selection, student experience, and program self-evaluation. RESULTS: Forty-six of 91 (50.5%) identified programs responded. These SSRPs collectively offered 1842 positions with a mean 3.76 applicants per placement. Most programs (78.3%, n = 36/46) required students to independently secure a research supervisor. A formal curriculum existed among 61.4% (n = 27/44) of programs. Few programs (5.9%, n = 2/34) offered an integrated clinical observership. Regarding evaluation, 11.4% (n = 5/44) of programs tracked subsequent research productivity and 27.5% (n = 11/40) conducted long-term impact assessments. CONCLUSIONS: Canadian SSRPs are highly competitive with the responsibility of selection primarily with the individual research supervisor rather than a centralized committee. Most programs offered students opportunities to develop both research and communication skills. Presently, the majority of programs do not have a sufficient evaluation component. These findings indicate that SSRPs may benefit from refinement of selection processes and more robust evaluation of their utility. To address this challenge, the authors describe a logic model that provides a set of core outcomes which can be applied as a framework to guide program evaluation of SSRPs.
33
Making a Difference in Science Education
M. Kevin Eagan, Sylvia Hurtado, Mitchell J. Chang et al. · American Educational Research Journal · 2013 · 539 citations · Full text
The Physician-Scientist Career Pipeline in 2005
Timothy J. Ley, León E. Rosenberg · JAMA · 2005 · 362 citations
Bonnie Simpson Mason, William A. Ross, Gezzer Ortega et al. · Clinical Orthopaedics and Related Research · 2016 · 229 citations · Full text