Journal of Social Welfare and Family Law · 2017 · 30 citations · 4 references
LawFamily LawHuman Rights LawChildren's RightsHuman RightsSurrogacy LawAssisted Reproduction Across BordersCross-border SurrogacyIntended Parent RightsParental RightsReproductive RightsSurrogacy Across BordersBest Interests AnalysisBest Interests AssessmentChildren's Best InterestsInternational Surrogacy LawRights Of Surrogates
This article examines the approach of the European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR) to assessing the best interests of the child in three recent cases of cross-border surrogacy, namely Mennesson v France, Labassee v France and Paradiso and Campanelli v Italy. It is argued that these cases reveal inconsistency in the ECtHR’s assessment of the best interests of the child. In Mennesson and Labassee, the ECtHR found that the national authorities’ refusal to legally recognise the relationships between the children and the intended parents amounted to a violation of Article 8 ECHR, whereas no violation was found in Paradiso. A notable distinguishing feature of Paradiso was that there was no genetic relationship between the child and the intended parents, and it is this point that seemingly led the Court to assess the best interests of that child differently to the others.
4
Committee on the rights of the child
Ghislain Vincent · Docs.school Publications · 2009 · 733 citations
Law, Human Rights Law, Pediatrics +10
Two Concepts of the Margin of Appreciation
G. Letsas · Oxford Journal of Legal Studies · 2006 · 201 citations