Does Integrated Reporting Matter to the Capital Market?

Shan Zhou, Roger Simnett, Wendy Green

Abacus · 2017 · 483 citations · 72 references

DOIFull text

Open access

Concepts

TL;DR

Integrated reporting is an emerging initiative designed to address the volume and disjointedness of traditional corporate reporting, yet its adoption has been slow due to a lack of clear evidence of benefits. The study aims to determine whether greater alignment with the IR framework reduces analyst forecast error. The authors use discretionary disclosures by Johannesburg Stock Exchange‑listed companies to assess this relationship. Higher IR alignment lowers analyst forecast error and reduces the cost of equity capital, even after controlling for financial transparency and standalone non‑financial reports, indicating that IR provides incremental value to the capital market.

Abstract

Integrated reporting (<IR>) is an emerging international corporate reporting initiative to address limitations to extant corporate reporting approaches, which are commonly criticized for being both voluminous and disjointed. While <IR> is gaining in popularity, current momentum has been limited due to a lack of clear evidence of its benefits. Utilizing the most suitable setting currently available, being discretionary disclosures made by listed companies on the Johannesburg Stock Exchange, this study provides evidence that analyst forecast error reduces as a company's level of alignment with the <IR> framework increases. Further, the improved alignment is associated with a subsequent reduction in the cost of equity capital for certain reporting companies. The results are obtained after controlling for factors relating to financial transparency and the issuance of standalone non-financial reports, which suggests that <IR> is providing incrementally useful information to the capital market over and above existing reporting mechanisms.

References

72