Law & Social Inquiry · 2017 · 16 citations · 14 references
Social SciencesAnthropologyInternational LawArmed ConflictEthnographyInternational Humanitarian LawCivil-military RelationsContextual InterpretationLegal AnthropologyLegal ClassificationActorsCase Study InterpretationEthnographic Field NotesExplanatory Case StudyMilitary ImageryMilitary LawSituated ParticipationSociological Model
International law dictates that actors in armed conflicts must distinguish between combatants and civilians. But how do legal actors assess the legality of a military operation after the fact? I analyze a civil proceeding for compensation by victims of a German-led airstrike in Afghanistan. The court treated military video as key evidence. I show how lawyers, judges, and expert witnesses categorized those involved by asking what a “military viewer” would make of the pictures. During the hearing, they avoided the categories of combatants/civilians; the military object resisted legal coding. I examine the decision in its procedural context, using ethnographic field notes and legal documents. I combine two ethnomethodological analytics: a trans-sequential approach and membership categorization analysis. I show the value of this combination for the sociological analysis of legal practice. I also propose that legal practitioners should use this approach to assess military viewing as a concerted, situated activity.
14
The Presentation of Self in Everyday Life.
Kaspar D. Naegele, Erving Goffman · American Sociological Review · 1956 · 26.2K citations
New and old wars: organized violence in a global era
Choice Reviews Online · 1999 · 2.1K citations · Full text
Social Sciences, Conflict Studies, International Relations +12
A tutorial on membership categorization
Emanuel A. Schegloff · Journal of Pragmatics · 2006 · 762 citations
Categorization and the Moral Order
John D. Brewer, Lena Jayyusi · British Journal of Sociology · 1985 · 461 citations