Learning from “Shadow Security:” Why Understanding Non-Compliant Behaviors Provides the Basis for Effective Security

Iacovos Kirlappos, Simon Parkin, M. Angela Sasse

2014 · 92 citations · 22 references

Concepts

TL;DR

Security researchers have long sought to explain why employees fail to follow organizational security policies, yet prior work has treated compliance as a simple binary choice. Our interview study uncovered a third compliance response—shadow security—where employees devise hidden workarounds that, while less secure, balance job demands and risk, suggesting that organizations should learn from these practices rather than suppress them.

Abstract

Over the past decade, security researchers and practitioners have tried to understand why employees do not comply with organizational security policies and mechanisms. Past re-search has treated compliance as a binary decision: people comply, or they do not. From our analysis of 118 in-depth interviews with individuals (employees in a large multinational organization) about security non-compliance, a 3rd response emerges: shadow security. This describes the instances where security-conscious employees who think they cannot comply with the prescribed security policy create a more fitting alter-native to the policies and mechanisms created by the organization’s official security staff. These workarounds are usually not visible to official security and higher management – hence ‘shadow security’. They may not be as secure as the ‘official’ policy would be in theory, but they reflect the best compromise staff can find between getting the job done and managing the risks that the assets they understand face. We conclude that rather than trying to ‘stamp out’ shadow security practices, organizations should learn from them: they provide a starting point ‘workable’ security: solutions that offer effective security and fit with the organization’s business, rather than impede it.

References

22