Social Science Computer Review · 2002 · 86 citations · 20 references
BusinessDecision SciencesStrategyForecastingRisk AnalysisUncertainty QuantificationAdaptation PlanningForecasting MethodsForecasting UncertaintyFuture ScenariosRobust Decision MakingScenario ForecastingAdaptive Decision-makingAnalytic ThinkingDecision Under Deep UncertaintyScenario BuildingScenario GenerationScenario PlanningScenario-based ForecastingStrategic Anticipation
Surprise disrupts plans, and reliance on formal analytic methods can heighten susceptibility by focusing on single‑point forecasts, diverting attention from information crucial for understanding and planning for surprise. The authors aim to use computer‑assisted reasoning with simulation models to generate large ensembles of plausible future scenarios. They combine computer‑assisted reasoning with simulation models to produce these ensembles. The framework supports a robust adaptive planning approach that, as shown in a long‑term global sustainability example, offers greater insight into surprise vulnerabilities and improves decision makers’ ability to mitigate surprise effects.
Surprise takes many forms, all tending to disrupt plans and planning systems. Reliance by decision makers on formal analytic methodologies can increase susceptibility to surprise as such methods commonly use available information to develop single-point forecasts or probability distributions of future events. In doing so, traditional analyses divert attention from information potentially important to understanding and planning for effects of surprise. The authors propose employing computer-assisted reasoning methods in conjunction with simulation models to create large ensembles of plausible future scenarios. This framework supports a robust adaptive planning (RAP) approach to reasoning under the conditions of complexity and deep uncertainty that normally defeat analytic approaches. The authors demonstrate, using the example of planning for long-term global sustainability, how RAP methods may offer greater insight into the vulnerabilities inherent in several types of surprises and enhance decision makers’ ability to construct strategies that will mitigate or minimize the effects of surprise.
20