Consumer-Choice Health Plan

Alain C. Enthoven

New England Journal of Medicine · 1978 · 351 citations · 8 references

Concepts

TL;DR

The country’s medical financing system is plagued by severe inflation and inequity, driven by fee‑for‑service payments, third‑party intermediaries, cost‑reimbursing hospitals, tax‑subsidized insurance favoring the well‑to‑do, and regressive employment coverage. Analyses show that prior national insurance proposals and direct government regulation cannot resolve these issues, whereas cost controls through incentives and regulated private competition are most likely to succeed.

Abstract

The financing system for medical costs in this country suffers from severe inflation and inequity. The tax-supported system of fee for service for doctors, third-party intermediaries and cost reimbursement for hospitals produces inflation by rewarding cost-increasing behavior and failing to provide incentives for economy. The system is inequitable because the government pays more on behalf of those who choose more costly systems of care, because tax benefits subsidize the health insurance of the well-to-do, while not helping many low-income people, and because employment health insurance does not guarantee continuity of coverage and is regressive in its financing. Analysis of previous proposals for national health insurance shows none to be capable of solving most of these problems. Direct economic regulation by government will not improve the situation. Cost controls through incentives and regulated competition in the private sector are most likely to be effective.

References

8