The Organization of Career Lines: Equal Employment Opportunity and Status Advancement in a Federal Bureaucracy

Thomas A. DiPrete, Whitman T. Soule

American Sociological Review · 1986 · 63 citations · 16 references

Concepts

TL;DR

In the early 1970s, the federal government mandated intensified efforts to promote upward mobility of lower‑level civil service employees. The study investigates how these federal upward‑mobility programs affected the careers of minorities, women, and lower‑level employees in a federal agency. The programs led to a higher share of upper‑level entry‑grade positions filled by promotion of lower‑level employees, benefiting women and minorities, yet when controlling for other factors, female and non‑white lower‑level workers did not have higher promotion probabilities than male/white peers, and the growth cannot be explained by supply/demand effects.

Abstract

In the early 1970s the federal government mandated intensified efforts to further the upward mobility of lower-level employees in the federal civil service. This paper examines the consequences of this effort for the careers of minorities and women, in particular, and lower-level employees in general, for an agency of the federal government. A greater proportion of upper-level entry-grade positions were filled by promotion after the implementation of these programs. This growth cannot be explained away by supply/demand effects. Because 90 percent of lower-level employees were women and 50 percent were non-white, the greater proportion of upper-level positions filled through promotion of lower-level employees benefitted these groups, though the benefits of higher promotion rates for non-whites were offset by other factors. However, female and non-white lower-level employees did not have a greater probability for promotion than did male and white lower-level employees, respectively, when otherfactors were controlled for. The implications of the statistical findings are discussed, and an interpretation is given of how upward mobility programs fit within the overall personnel policy of the federal government.

References

16