Journal of Aesthetic Education · 1992 · 11 citations · 0 references
HumanitiesMusicologyMusic AestheticsMusic PsychologyMusic TheoryExpression In MusicMusic ImageryMusic PerceptionMusical ExperienceMusical KnowledgeMusical MeaningCognitive Aesthetics Of MusicEmbodied Musical ExperienceExtra-musical MeaningNonverbal InvolvementPerformative AestheticsPhenomenology Of Musical Experience
Many have claimed that because music is essentially a nonverbal medium, the experience of music cannot be translated into and communicated in words.' Attempts to formulate musical experience in words, according to this view, either trivialize the essence of music or fail to do justice to the richness of the aesthetic experience. Of course in some forms of music, such as opera, oratorio, lieder, the text is intrinsically related to the music. In these, knowledge of the words often heightens the musical experience, even though some purists would argue that knowing the words should not be essential to the enjoyment and proper of the music. The same argument has been used in relation to images suggested by music. Thus program music, which is specifically written to represent or imitate particular scenes or events (e.g., a flowing brook, the sounds of battle, horses galloping, heartbeats) is seen as an exception to the way in which music typically means. Music according to this school does not refer beyond itself, and thus such associations are extramusical-extraneous and superfluous to the experience. At most, they contribute to a superficial of the music. If words and images are irrelevant to the experience of music, it would seem to follow that neither language nor imagery play a significant role in musical learning and performance. It would follow that the only way to acquire proficiency in music is to practice diligently and self-critically, and to listen very actively so as to cultivate the inner hearing that promotes the experience of a living whole. For example, Leopold Auer, a great violin virtuoso of the nineteenth century and the teacher of (among others) Ephrem Zimbalist, Sr., and Jascha Heifitz, in 1921 published a book, Violin Playing as I Teach It, in which he said: