Planning To Perform: Evaluation Models For City Planners

Leora Waldner

Berkeley Planning Journal · 2011 · 23 citations · 20 references

DOIFull text

Open access

Concepts

TL;DR

City planners produce diverse planning products, including area plans and zoning ordinances. The study investigates whether and how planners evaluate their planning products. The authors employ a three‑pronged method—reviewing planning textbooks, plan evaluation provisions, and actual evaluations—to identify post‑hoc evaluation models for comprehensive plans, area plans, and zoning ordinances. The study finds that incentives and disincentives influence planners’ willingness to conduct evaluations and proposes new directions and tools for future city planning evaluation.

Abstract

Planners create a wide array of planning products, from area plans to zoning ordinances. How, if at all, are these products evaluated? This article uses a three-pronged approach to identify post-hoc evaluation models for three common products: comprehensive plans, area plans, and zoning ordinances. The three-pronged approach examines the planning textbooks, the evaluation provisions in the plans themselves, and the actual evaluations. After probing the evaluation models, the article discusses incentives and disincentives for evaluations, revealing factors that may make planners less inclined to conduct evaluations. The article concludes by exploring new directions and tools for city planning evaluation.

References

20